Hey Anthile, I'm trying not to derail, so I thought I'd reply here.
I think I've found a way of properly expressing what I was trying to say:
I don't mind trolls. Spam is an issue I think, but dishonesty, sock puppets and so on I don't mind. I really enjoy some of their posts, and XIII especially has a writing style and a clarity of expression that I find very attractive. That's just me personally though and I'm not going to fight any decisions made.
And I agree with what you said about romanticising villains, which I'll take to be a simple way of saying we tend to read too much good into people/situations, although this tendency goes both ways, and the labels we use are inadequate.
But anyway, I have no opinion on his value as a moral person.
Btw, what was the reason for LaberintoPassionth being banned?