Reluctantly
Resident disMember
- Local time
- Yesterday 4:13 PM
- Joined
- Mar 14, 2010
- Messages
- 3,135
But why feel the need to do this? He wasn't ever the mafia's top suspect of cop.. so all that shouting and for what? what did he achieve? He lynched the towns people and didn't steer steer the lynches on to mafia.. Like I only see his role as a success if he was a bent cop.. which as a role doesn't exists in this game. As I say, wouldn't it have been safer being a cop, and a townie under the radar.
And the biggest balls up was his (attributed) arrogance in regards to Eyes. What I have a problem with is the fact that we had a cop that town couldn't trust... and in OUR game, not an imaginary super meta game.. all that meta crap served no purpose.
Yeah it really does take eyes off the mafia and onto the Townies. Is counter-intuitive to me, unless he expected to lynch a mafia. But even then, it kind of throws everything into so much confusion I don't think Town would have much chance to come together in the end. He would have been a suspect regardless and thrown off mafia reads.
Artsu was a handicap to mafia as well in ways. There was never any contribution from him in the mafia chat so I had no idea if he was playing rogue to his own strategy and would mess up anything we planned. Like in the last round if we were working together winning would've been a lot simpler. We just wait for two votes on Hado (sinny & rumi/neb were safe bets) then just spike it and win. But we couldn't do that as we knew he wouldn't help, so it made more sense to make the others aware of this strategy to deceive them on the voting patterns.
I mean...you did that anyway. And he never messed with your strategies. He was simply absent in terms of playing the game. He was literally an untouchable player that was actually a center-piece to the game. It throws off town when they expect there are three mafia players when in actuality there was only two, statistically lowering the chances of a successful lynch and making it so that it would have been impossible to get all the mafia, unless he was the last remaining one at some point. Town getting a mafia lynch also helps them have more to pinpoint other mafia as well, so it's kind of extra lame that he was gone like he was.
If I was moderating this game I think I'd be very hesitant to have replacements, just because it makes the entire posting history of that spot up until that moment in time redundant as a fresh player takes it, builds up a fresh impression, etc. I thought QT's moderation was fine.
mmmmm, but Art was never playing to begin with. He never said anything relevant, except that he doesn't feel like playing and will post just so he doesn't get modkilled...If he was a townie it wouldn't be that big a deal, but as a mafia non-participant that holds a vote, it ruins the game. if he was modkilled, there would have been another round. If he was replaced, Town might have had more to work with and a higher chance of targeting a mafia, especially given Hado's strategy.