• OK, it's on.
  • Please note that many, many Email Addresses used for spam, are not accepted at registration. Select a respectable Free email.
  • Done now. Domine miserere nobis.

How do you know you're INTP?

Mondorius

Oh..?
Local time
Today 8:11 AM
Joined
Aug 16, 2009
Messages
143
---
Location
Canada
What's INTP?

...


:phear:


Seriously, much like Yeti, I've repeatedly been typed as one. The descriptions given of an INTP suit me rather well. Being same personnality types doesn't make us all the same. Am I sure? No. I'm not that well versed into the MBTI and the difference between my P and J isn't enormous. And then like Yeti said, there's outside influence and evolution...
 

Philovitist

Yeah!
Local time
Today 8:11 AM
Joined
Mar 10, 2011
Messages
159
---
Location
SC. SOS.
I know I'm INTP because the test told me so (sure, sometimes it says INTJ, but whatever). But the INTJ profile definitely doesn't fit me as well as the INTJ one. The INTJ one is creepy.
 

WSidis

Redshirt
Local time
Today 8:11 AM
Joined
Mar 18, 2011
Messages
17
---
Location
Waltham, MA
I agree with the OP, there probably are plenty of pseudo-intuitives out there.

I know I'm INTP though, N is my biggest score and my best function...:evil: (big dick icon)
 

crippli

disturbed
Local time
Today 2:11 PM
Joined
Jan 15, 2008
Messages
1,779
---
Well, I was recently banned from the other intp site for being non intp. Unfortunately this was done quickly, so it wasn't clarified what type that I was.

Istp has been mentioned. Also infj, enfp, enfj, infp, isfj, istj, intj, inxp, xnxp has been mentioned. And of course some intp typings. The latter with the most votes so far, maybe rivaled by infp and isfp, and for a little while on typologyC several intj typings.

Personally I'm more occupied with finding out what gender my brain is, I've been typed on this as well, it, she, he, something.

I would like to think I am intpish, but it's mostly a guess. Could be something else. I just tally the votes as they occur and decide on with what is on top at some point. To me the path to get there is more interesting then the destination. So opinions are appreciated(just not something too dramatic, like nonintp or such things, as I don't consider this to be overly helpful...)
 

Acy

Antonio, El Conquistador de Amor
Local time
Today 7:11 AM
Joined
Mar 26, 2011
Messages
2
---
Location
Houston, TX
How do I know I'm an INTP? I don't know, man! People tell me I am. I sense it. I FEEL it! I'm the decider, and I've decided I'm an INTP!

I do a lot of those anecdotal things they mention in the test results. Like brutalizing people when they make irrational arguments, and correcting them when they make false assertions. Even strangers! I engage in discussions with people to show off things I think I know. I'm great at starting projects but often do not see them through once I've gotten a feel for the process involved. Nothing pisses me off more than the willfully ignorant. Except for the pridefully ignorant. I'm from Texas.
 

Hammond

Average Philosopher
Local time
Today 8:11 AM
Joined
Jan 12, 2011
Messages
9
---
Location
Logical Heaven
How do I know?

-The tests say so.

-I'm good with language, mathematics, and symbolic logic.

-I'm spend quite a bit of time by myself. It's how I recharge. However, I am quite social in certain circles (philosophy buffs, computer geeks).

-Real world application is not my biggest concern.


I do have some reservations though. I've seen streaks of ISTJ in myself as well.
 

Iuanes

Member
Local time
Today 8:11 AM
Joined
Mar 2, 2010
Messages
76
---
Bleh, being at good at or enjoying sports doesn't mean your S, it could just mean you have a high kinesthetic intelligence. Ne is HUGE in sports, because thinking kills performance, having an automatic external processing unit is awesome, Si comes into play as well if you care about what you're doing.

We are still animals too and need to move. Lots of people here seem to like dancing, but I would never say they were S because of it.

I'm more an INTP than anything else. Sci Fi, yes, abstraction yes, too much thinking yes, too much procrastination, yes, truth is ultimate, yes, flitting interest, yes etc. etc.

And I would probably direct people to Paul James profile if they wanted to know me flat out (for the most part).
 

baj

Member
Local time
Today 8:11 AM
Joined
Dec 5, 2010
Messages
27
---
Location
On a farm.


I believe I watched one sporting event in the last two years.



  • Prefer fantasy/sci fi
Over what? I like various forms of literature and non-fiction. I used to read more sci-fi and books in general. I've read the Dune saga. I've read the Foundation Trilogy. OH wait...not this thread.

  • Happy with theory with no practical application
What?

  • Preference for architecture & design
I like photos of buildings. Does that count?


  • Music/photography/computer predilections
I do USE a computer (obviously).

  • Detachment, extreme independence

From what? Actually I am, sort of. Does this mean we can all become INTPs by reading "Co-dependent no more"?

  • Other ...
 

a detached retina

Active Member
Local time
Today 8:11 AM
Joined
Jan 12, 2011
Messages
192
---
Well, if you observe how Chewbacca and others present their arguments on this site, I think you should be able to tell whether it's likely he is INTP or not.

I'm either INFJ or INTP. I have Ti and Fe.

If you're basing it just on the judging functions you could also be an ISFJ or an ENTP or even ISTP.
 

jdnel99

Josh
Local time
Today 7:11 AM
Joined
Apr 4, 2011
Messages
10
---
Location
Nebraska
I'm pretty sure I'm an INTP, I fit all of the categories, and from the research I've done, I've always acted like an INTP it seems without me knowing it. I also took the test without knowing what any of the outcomes would be like or what the I N T or P meant, so that's also a plus. I always had really poor social skills and manners until I found out that I was an INTP and was able to work on them properly. I'm going to go to college to study physics and mathematics, and I decided this before I knew I was an INTP, then saw that those were some of the main career areas for INTPs. I've always been unnaturally logical, although I can never properly communicate verbally to the extent that I would like, I do much better in writing, which most INTPs have done. (for example Thomas Jefferson was terrible verbally, but he wrote some of the most beautiful documents of all time, and he was suspected to be an INTP). When I was 16 I wrote an 18 page paper (single spaced) to my parents explaining why marijuana was not bad, and they were stunned at its logic and beauty (of the format , not necessarily the topic). I'm not 100% sure I am an INTP though, this is because I can usually pour my passion into my writing (not fictional, or poetry, but when making a persuasive argument [or any other argument] I've heard people say that they can "feel the passion"). Said fact aside, I still think the best way to describe my personality would be as an INTP. Feel free to judge my character, I would love to get your opinion.
 

digital angel

Well-Known Member
Local time
Today 8:11 AM
Joined
Mar 16, 2011
Messages
554
---
Location
Tax World/In my Mind
I'm pretty sure I'm an INTP, I fit all of the categories, and from the research I've done, I've always acted like an INTP it seems without me knowing it. I also took the test without knowing what any of the outcomes would be like or what the I N T or P meant, so that's also a plus. I always had really poor social skills and manners until I found out that I was an INTP and was able to work on them properly. I'm going to go to college to study physics and mathematics, and I decided this before I knew I was an INTP, then saw that those were some of the main career areas for INTPs. I've always been unnaturally logical, although I can never properly communicate verbally to the extent that I would like, I do much better in writing, which most INTPs have done. (for example Thomas Jefferson was terrible verbally, but he wrote some of the most beautiful documents of all time, and he was suspected to be an INTP). When I was 16 I wrote an 18 page paper (single spaced) to my parents explaining why marijuana was not bad, and they were stunned at its logic and beauty (of the format , not necessarily the topic). I'm not 100% sure I am an INTP though, this is because I can usually pour my passion into my writing (not fictional, or poetry, but when making a persuasive argument [or any other argument] I've heard people say that they can "feel the passion"). Said fact aside, I still think the best way to describe my personality would be as an INTP. Feel free to judge my character, I would love to get your opinion.

Sound like you've made up your mind. Sounds like you're INTP.

I don't know that the ability to pour your passion into writing disqualifies you as INTP. I have a background in philosophy and loved to write. I still do. I also love being a tax attorney.

Good luck in college. Math and Physics sounds wonderful.
 

jdnel99

Josh
Local time
Today 7:11 AM
Joined
Apr 4, 2011
Messages
10
---
Location
Nebraska
Sound like you've made up your mind. Sounds like you're INTP.

I don't know that the ability to pour your passion into writing disqualifies you as INTP. I have a background in philosophy and loved to write. I still do. I also love being a tax attorney.

Good luck in college. Math and Physics sounds wonderful.

Thank you, I've been able to discover who I really am from a very early age (one of the philosophies my parents taught me is to figure things out for myself, and so I figured out myself for myself) and so that's probably why I sounded so sure I was an INTP.
 

MissQuote

kickin' at a tin can
Local time
Today 5:11 AM
Joined
Mar 24, 2011
Messages
1,169
---
I don't know positively that I am.

I know it is they type I most often have scored on various online tests for several years now, and like the person a couple of posts up, I knew nothing about any of the types or what any of it meant at all the first time I took a test and was typed as such, although I hold being typed INTP, mostly consistantly, over a period of time to have more weight than a single blind time.

But I still haven't learned enough about the whole system to know what I even think about it as a accurate gauge. At this point I am looking at it as an interesting tool and reference point worth further investigation.
 

Zionoxis

Active Member
Local time
Today 8:11 AM
Joined
Jan 30, 2011
Messages
437
---
Location
USA
I don't believe I am ISTP, but I still float around in happy I/E +NTP land.....darn me and my constant fight for introversion/extroversion.

Now, who wants waffles?
 

Bird

Banned
Local time
Today 4:11 PM
Joined
Oct 1, 2010
Messages
1,175
---
How do we know anything?
 

Bird

Banned
Local time
Today 4:11 PM
Joined
Oct 1, 2010
Messages
1,175
---
Duplicate speculation, popular theory.


And I would love waffles as long as you dye the batter green and there is lots of various fresh fruits to cover the waffle with.
 

SpaceYeti

Prolific Member
Local time
Today 6:11 AM
Joined
Aug 14, 2010
Messages
5,592
---
Location
Crap
... Did you just answer your own question?

Also, does anyone ever want to spell "question" like "qwestion"? It's an odd thing my fingers always try to slip by me.
 

Bird

Banned
Local time
Today 4:11 PM
Joined
Oct 1, 2010
Messages
1,175
---
... Did you just answer your own question?

Also, does anyone ever want to spell "question" like "qwestion"? It's an odd thing my fingers always try to slip by me.


Yes. I do that often.

My ability to reason takes a second to catch
up to my wandering mind.


No. I never make that typo. Ever.
Freak.
 

RobdoR

Active Member
Local time
Today 4:11 PM
Joined
Dec 12, 2007
Messages
156
---
I first thought I was an ISTP. The meyers-briggs system doesn't do a very good job of differentiating the two.

It's much more clear if you go with the Keirsey system (same letters...slightly different classification). He breaks it up a bit differently. The S / N is the most important divide. S is concrete thinking and N is abstract thinking.

N's like to think about stuff
S's like to do stuff
 

Renegade

Redshirt
Local time
Today 5:11 AM
Joined
Apr 8, 2011
Messages
4
---
Well, the entire Myers Briggs personality type is based off of set stereotypes which are somewhat true, yet never accurate (Stereotypes that is. Stereotypes are all inaccurate to some extent). The closest I've scored (as others have said) is INTP with the I and the N being solid fact, and the S and the J a little interchangeable.

Also, do people really have set personalities? I'm have a quite different personality from when I was four (as I expect many people do)... Also since environments call for different types, there's really too many variables to narrow yourself down accurately.

Architect seems to describe me with a hint of Mastermind and whatever the heck the ISTP is. Anything else is just residue from my oppressive private school of pseudo-intelligent philosophers...
 

Machiavelli

Redshirt
Local time
Today 1:11 PM
Joined
Apr 29, 2011
Messages
7
---
Location
Belgium
My result was always INTP when I did the test. I think the reason why I'm telling this is because I always felt people don't know me ("real me", or the way I view myself), or I can't show my personality properly.

Myers-Briggs did some good work showing what kind of different personalities people can be but indeed like somebody wrote in this threat people can try to make their ideal personality, how they want to be viewed or even how they view them self.


I think personality is something deeper and less rigid. But M-B personalties work for a lot of people, they can identify them self and identify with others in a limited but useful way.

Everybody who got the INTP result is connected in the way they all got INTP as result. This alone is interesting in my opinion.

ps: sorry for my bad English, I'm a French/Dutch guy. I'm actually more familiar with the French internet community.

ps 2: If somebody could have an idea what type I could be, you can always PM me. I always like to know what people think of me, or what they think of the way I make forum posts.
 

scorpiomover

The little professor
Local time
Today 1:11 PM
Joined
May 3, 2011
Messages
3,383
---
Whenever I did the MBTI tests in my teens and twenties, I always came up as INTP. These days, my I and T is a lot more relaxed. Occasionally, I come up as ENTP, or INFP, or maybe when I'm being really sociable, as ENFP. I guess I'm more flexible on the I/E and T/F because I'm a P, and change a lot. But I always come up as NP. Even when I did personality tests that had nothing to do the MBTI/Jungian system, the answers were still basically really logical, the same as you'd expect from an INTP.

Anyway, looking at your list:

Prefer fantasy/sci fi
Happy with theory with no practical application
Preference for architecture & design
Music/photography/computer predilections
Detachment, extreme independence
 

Raskolnikov

Redshirt
Local time
Today 8:11 AM
Joined
May 10, 2011
Messages
24
---
Location
Canada
How do I know for sure I'm an INTP? I don't. Though based on the research I've done, while I do identify with some other types to an extent, I most identify with INTP. Am I a "fake N"? I doubt it, as I consistently scored N before I knew what N was or that S's were supposedly (and wrongly) frowned upon, and moreover I simply don't identify with S nearly as strongly.

One thing I don't get is why so many people like to attach certain interests and activities to types. ie. "If you like skiing you're an ISTP; if you like fantasy you're an INTP" etc.

To me this seems completely ridiculous. I mean, sure, maybe a larger percentage of X type likes Y activity than Z type, but this cannot possibly be considered an accurate indicator. How absurd would it be to suggest that out of the 450-some-odd-million X types in the entire world, not even a small percentage of them like mainstream Y interest? Think of how many tens of millions of people would be mis-typed due to this widespread fallacy/stereotyping; even if only 5% of INTP's enjoyed skiing (which is probably far too low a number, but just to make my point clear), that would still make for about 20 million mis-types. Yet this is essentially what I'm constantly seeing on every MBTI board I visit.
 

Ghost1986

Active Member
Local time
Today 6:11 PM
Joined
Feb 9, 2009
Messages
292
---
Location
The United States.
through a professional and several online tests i have come through as INTP. through my own research though i think otherwise.

I-yes that's me
N-i am not sure about this one. if you make a line marked N-10 to S+10 i would say i am at most N-2. i think my sensing and intuition are very smiler. personally i would prefer more S than N.
T-no doubt about it.
P-when i took the test with a shrink she said i was borderline. she then asked if i felt it was ok for people to have different opinions when i know mine are obviously right. at that time i said yes it was ok. as i get older not so much. i would say i am becoming more J than P.
 

boondockbabe

I am a little cold hearted
Local time
Today 7:11 AM
Joined
Apr 21, 2011
Messages
342
---
Location
BFE Missouri
I've come to suspect that people frequently mistype themselves - most commonly between the N-S divide. Probably because one of the failings of MBTI is that nobody wants to be a Sensor, the impression it gives is that if you are one you are lacking in imagination and brainpower. In my observations I've been fooled by ESFP's who come off as NF's.

On the INTP, there have been pensive, analytical people who I've worked with who I thought were INTP's, but have since decided were probably the S counterpart. On the online INTP forums (this and others) I'm pretty sure that a substantial proportion are S's, not N's. Some characteristics that distinguish the S instead of the N are ISTP's tend to be tool or sport oriented (snow sports in particular), of course the S attention to detail (one S who I worked with and I thought was an NT was previously an entomologist), and S's have more edge usually than INTP's.

So how do you know? I do through the Paul James profile and other clues, predominantly

  • Prefer fantasy/sci fi
  • Happy with theory with no practical application
  • Preference for architecture & design
  • Music/photography/computer predilections
  • Detachment, extreme independence
  • Other ...
So how do you know? Are you sure?

We have actually had this discussion before and while I can not tell you how many of theese tests I have taken(too many to count) I always test out INT and then the J-P bounces back and forth leaning on the P side most of the time. But I do see some traits. I do wonder sometimes. what with my "Thrillseeking" personality.
It is somthing I have ponderd for a while now Its a test. It is only as honest as you are with youself. So it could possibly just be the profile of who you want yourself to be. I am fortunate enough at my age to be familiar and comfortable with who I am. Plus it didn't matter to me. I didnt know what kind of test I was taking. I did'nt find out till after the test was over. So I did'nt know the difference between one or the other. at the time they were just letters. It has nothing to do with sure or not. The problem for me is coming to believe it- it is still surreal.
 

Roboman

Member
Local time
Today 2:11 PM
Joined
Apr 19, 2011
Messages
54
---
I know because my knowledge has streched to a certain point where I just know.
 

Abraxas

γνῶσις
Local time
Today 3:11 PM
Joined
Apr 1, 2010
Messages
327
---
You are an INTP if you were classically conditioned to be one. That doesn't mean you always were or always will be. At the moment I, for instance, am approximately: I-E(70-30%)N-S(60-40%)F-T(50-50%)P-J(60-40%)
 

Valentas

Well-Known Member
Local time
Today 1:11 PM
Joined
Jun 20, 2012
Messages
506
---
Mhm, I have some time today to ponder over my development again...

During the year of university in CS program, I did not delve into programming only. What I found is that in most cases, I did not tend to stick with one idea and explore it deeply. I went from one to another, satisfied with marginal understanding of it. In my opinion, that my signify that I am not Ti, but maybe Te. Not sure about that though. I tried to research everything about particular stuff I wanted but time pressures and other stuff to do forced me to leave the problem altogether.

Same stuff happened with programming languages. I explored many languages but did not become competent in any because I find learning new language very tedious. Except Haskell, that was new and interesting way to program.

I took up physical exercises for some time but did not stick wiht my goals as coursework and work ate most of the time. And I never missed that even though my current idea is to undertake something different like karate or something of this sort because I am very bored to pick up things and put them down(bodybuilding). I started this routine several times but never stuck with it for more than 2 months. I mostly want to undertake something new and thus I am considering some martial arts. I get very mentally tired without going out and in my opinion, training physically would help.

Now, I am interested in Sci-Fi but I see the other side of technology which will be used against human beings at some point. That makes me think hard about my role in technology. On the one hand, one has no excuse to not develop something new but on the other hand, I know that inventions will be used against me and others at some point. My biggest worry now is the issue of handling new technologies by people. Anyone with some research knows that there are classified projects going on and that people who run these things know that population would be able to handle new technologies and thus keep it under security. I see a need for spiritual evolution not technology. Because without it, we won't be able to handle tech. I certainly could but a lot crazies out there would not. This is one of the ideas I wrestled with for a long time because it applies to me and everyone on this planet.

I am not always happy with theory. I hate learning programming concepts without seeing why it's useful. If I can see applications, I will learn it. It's not that I don't like theory. It's because the time is limited for many things and I am trying to optimize as much as possible. You can't learn everything. I was in awe of software design patterns. They were so beautiful that I thought that I'd like to be software architect and not that much the implementer of logic. It seemed a lot more interesting to design stuff because one you have full design, implementation is a lot easier and only takes keyboard bashing.

I love music. Classical and instrument I play with - accordion. Here's an excerpt of a guy who is my role model for development of my abilities. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oPnVEVnI9-U I could probably spend 6 months or so to be able to play some of these compositions. I really like playing for myself and don't liek performing on stage.

Unfortunately, I see my detachment from others as a handicap. I did not make many friends during first year because I was busy reading, learning and people just did not like me almost always being on the higher level of thinking and topics I wanted to talk about. Most people were interested in more concrete ideas while I wanted to discuss say technology and future of humanity and to brainstorm what could happen. I just find it very interesting and most people turns off after some time when you talk about that. I am not interested in parties too which makes me really unattractive person to invite anywhere. I am looking for people who would like to go for a run or do some training together in the mornings. My goal is to try to speak with more people because even though I am very independent, it gets increasingly harder to not engage with others. I think that's a sign that my development should now be directed towards people more instead of myself.
 

Ex-User (9086)

Prolific Member
Local time
Today 1:11 PM
Joined
Nov 21, 2013
Messages
4,758
---
When every forum member and every person you meet and find credible tells you that you are INTP and when you find yourself as an INTP in multiple tests.
Also when multiple qualified specialists perform various tests on you, in a way, that makes you believe them that they come to the right conclusions when they call you an INTP.

It's all about how much information and believable sources you need to actually believe.
 

Spocksleftball

not right
Local time
Today 8:11 AM
Joined
Mar 10, 2014
Messages
163
---
Location
earth's center mass
I have not seen enough validation that MBTI is scientifically capable of determining how my type is recognizable in a generalized way. Most here seem to talk continuously about nonsense-- determining INTPness by how much they sleep, hand size, and music acuity.

I have been typed as INTP by a psychiatrist as part of a battery of tests. I spend most of the time, when on this topic, looking for validation of the process overall. Thus far, I see very little research confirming MBTI, or typology in general, as firm enough to give me any "reasonable beyond a doubt" conclusions. The jury, therefore, remains out.
 

sushi

Prolific Member
Local time
Today 1:11 PM
Joined
Aug 15, 2013
Messages
1,841
---
when you are allergic to stupid people. that already gives you a 50 % chance landing of accuracy.
 

Red myst

Abstract Utilitiarian
Local time
Today 7:11 AM
Joined
Mar 23, 2014
Messages
378
---
Location
Southern United States
Well, I use a combination of things. First started with wondering why I have always felt a little different from the general population, and have been evaluated with adult ADD in attentive . Then I discovered BMTI, took test various test many times. The test always come up IxxP. With only mild leanings in various orientations on the xx's. then I studied to online stereotype profiles online. I saw a little bit of me in some and more of me in others. I bought books by Lenora Thomson, And David Keirsey among others. I devoured and thing I could. I learned the function stack and studies the cognitive functions for a bit, and went back to the drawing board. I tested pretty much the same way in online test. I trolled fourms like this for a while, watched youtube videos, took fee based test with same results. I still don't positively know what I am. And my investigation started 3 years ago. I can identify with certain things like the Ne Ti loop. And I also identify a lot more with Si than Se. One of my problems is that I have a bit of an eclectic traits and eccentricities. For instance, I have good manual dexterity, which is why I have a knack with tools and playing my guitar, so that seems more sensor like. But there is not much else in the Se arsenal for me. Nothing at all athletic about me. I dont need a lot of sensory experiences.
Anyway back to your question, .... I reflected back on my past and evaluated my actions and motivations, and then re evaluated them. But with the lens of cognitive functions to view them through. I am always searching for new info, but I don't think I will get anywhere unless I start interacting with different types on these fourms to see where the intricate differences lie. I think my situation is that I am very balanced with the N,S,T,F and only have slight preferences which only come out within the context of my environment. I see very strong types, but I'm pretty moderate. I am going do let how I interact on these fourms help me ferrit it out.
 
Top Bottom