• OK, it's on.
  • Please note that many, many Email Addresses used for spam, are not accepted at registration. Select a respectable Free email.
  • Done now. Domine miserere nobis.

A New Description of the INTP

Lyra

Genesis Engineering Speciation
Local time
Today 5:33 AM
Joined
Jan 6, 2010
Messages
992
---
This is copied directly from The Book of Thoth, written before the MBTI's inception (hence the reference to "quoting scripture"). There's a fit, though:

[bimgx=350]http://i219.photobucket.com/albums/cc159/daimonion_october/2_12PrinceofSwords.jpg[/bimgx]

Prince of Swords:

This card represents the airy part of Air. With its particular interpretation, it is intellectual, it is a picture of the Mind as such. He rules from the 21st degree of Capricorn to the 20th degree of Aquarius.

The figure of this Prince is clothed with closely woven armour adorned with definite device, and the chariot which bears him suggests (even more closely) geometrical ideas. The chariot is drawn by winged children, looking and leaping irresponsibly in any direction that takes their fancy; they are not reined, but perfectly capricious. The chariot consequently is easy enough to move, but quite unable to progress in any definite direction except by accident. This is the perfect picture of the Mind.

On the head of this Prince is, nevertheless, a child's head radiant, for there is a secret crown in the nature of this card; if consecrated, it is exactly Tipareth.

The operation of his logical mental processes have reduced the Air, which is his element, to many diverse geometrical patterns, but in these there is no real plan; they are demonstrations of the power of the Mind without definite purpose. In his right hand is a lifted sword wherewith to create, but in his left hand is a sickle, so that what he creates he instantly destroys.

A person thus symbolized is purely intellectual. He is full of ideas and designs which tumble over each other. He is a mass of ideals unrelated to practical effort. He has all the apparatus of Thought in the highest degree, intensely clever, admirably rational, but unstable of purpose, and in reality indifferent to his own ideas, as knowing that any one of them is just as good as any other. He reduced everything to unreality by removing its substance and transmuting it to and ideal world or ratiocination which is purely formal and out of relation to any facts, even those upon which it is based.

In the Yi King, the airy part of Air is represented by the 57th hexagram, Sun. This is on of the most difficult figures in the book, on account of its ambivalence: it means both flexibility and penetration.

Immensely powerful because of its complete freedom from settled principles, capable of maintaining and putting forward any conceivable argument, insusceptible to regret or remorse, glib to "quote scripture" aptly and cunningly to support any thesis soever, indifferent to the fate of a contrary argument advanced two minutes earlier, impossible to defeat because any position is as good as any other, ready to enter into combination with the nearest element available, these elusive and elastic people are of value only when firmly mastered by creative will fortified with an intelligence superior to their own. In practice, this is rarely possible: there is no purchase to be had upon them, not even by pandering to their appetites. These may nevertheless be stormy, even uncontrollable. Faddists, devotees of drink, drugs, humanitarianism, music or religion, are often in this class; but when this is the case, there is still no stability. They wander from one cult or one vice to another, always brilliantly supporting with the fanaticism of a fixed conviction what is actually no more than the whim of the moment.

It is easy to be deceived by such people; for the manifestation itself has enormous potency: it is as if an imbecile offered one of the dialogues of Plato. They may in this way acquire a great reputation both for depth and breadth of mind.

--Crowley, The Book of Thoth.
 

Anthile

Steel marks flesh
Local time
Today 6:33 AM
Joined
Jan 10, 2009
Messages
3,987
---
Too pompous and not distinct enough to pass as a real description. However, definitely NT-ish.
 

Lyra

Genesis Engineering Speciation
Local time
Today 5:33 AM
Joined
Jan 6, 2010
Messages
992
---
I don't find it pompous. Crowley's writing does require some time to... acquaint to... though, so I can see why you think it is. That also applies to the subtlety of his meaning, and whether they're picked up on: he's definitely describing what we would call an 'INTP' or 'ENTP', not an NTJ.
 

Chronomar

NOPE
Local time
Today 5:33 AM
Joined
Oct 16, 2008
Messages
678
---
I find the picture very interesting. It is a geometric puppeteer with a sword ominously (or hopefully?) ready to sever the threads holding the puppets.

I interpret this as a person with control over other ideas, but is about to set them free. Or kill them. But...the person is wearing a silly hat?

Okay. It's an INTP.
 

Lyra

Genesis Engineering Speciation
Local time
Today 5:33 AM
Joined
Jan 6, 2010
Messages
992
---
The text describes the picture, and the significance of the symbols it contains. The picture itself is primary-- the text is just exegesis upon it. A few moments thought would have revealed that.

It's the Prince of Swords card from The Thoth Tarot.

Edit: note, for example, how the air in the picture is divided into geometrical shapes, and how the non-human elements are all geometrically abstract. That's... explained in the text. Yeah.
 

Chronomar

NOPE
Local time
Today 5:33 AM
Joined
Oct 16, 2008
Messages
678
---
Quite right, I did read the text. However, I preferred to comment on the picture because, well, it was more interesting to me.

A question: how do you think this new description of the INTP is different from the old descriptions? What makes it better/worse?

Moreover, are there descriptions (by this author) which would fit other types? Are they as accurate in your mind?
 

Geminii

Consultant, inventor, project innovator
Local time
Today 12:33 PM
Joined
Jan 7, 2010
Messages
222
---
Location
Perth, Australia
The Prince or Swords (and, in later decades, the King of Swords) has been my self-card in the Tarot for quite a while, and for similar reason.
 
Top Bottom