• OK, it's on.
  • Please note that many, many Email Addresses used for spam, are not accepted at registration. Select a respectable Free email.
  • Done now. Domine miserere nobis.

Why are we here? (on this forum)

88sansui

Redshirt
Local time
Today 4:43 PM
Joined
Aug 2, 2008
Messages
1
---
Location
Pittsburgh, PA, USA
I'll never be able to convey properly what I need to say here for two reasons.
1. I can not think in a linear fashion; it's more 3D. 3D does not translate well into a string of words.
2. I simply can't type fast enough to keep up so most of it gets lost and then I keep going back and rewriting things and changing the order of things which really doesn't help.
The whole idea of an INTP forum is counterintuitive. I think. It seems to me that to an INTP, the need to belong to a group would be a foreign concept. And yet, here is a 'group' of INTPs. There may be an explanation for this phenomenon though. Is it possible that most of the non-INTPs see themselves and others in a completely different way than we do? Do we see the world divided between ourselves on on side and everyone else on the other side? I'll stop writing in the form of questions now and make statements instead. Other people don't break it down that way. They just don't see thinks in those terms. They categorize people by social status, interests, etc. Like, " I'm into Harley-Davidsons and he's into golf so we must be very different people". Or, "I enjoy wine and the arts and she likes Starbucks and indie music so we must be very different people". Then they all feel the need to advertize to everyone else what group they belong too. They do this by how they dress what they drive, where they socialize etc. And these things are all very important to them. To me, when I see someone dressed up in one of those costumes like a skater or a hippie or a country-clubber or a sports team fan or a biker or geek or anything else at all, I instantly lose respect for them. I think it is silly to divide things up that way. I think they are all non-INTPs and just look at things completely different. As if they slice the onion top to bottom to divide it up and we slice it side to side. Since they all tend to slice the same way, they can all relate to each other rather easily and so they need to wear their costumes and have their cliques and groups just to have some kind of separation among themselves to simplify things but to us, separating people that way makes no sense and just looks stupid. So we are sort of left on the outside at least in our own perception of things. We aren't outcasts by any means. We actually blend in quite well precisely because we don't wear costumes. When one of the others talks with one of us, I think they are often quite surprised at what they find. They may immediately feel a sense of inferiority or even feel naked because we can see right through them in a way that they can perceive (if we allow them to) and it gives them that awkward feeling so they may accuse us of being arrogant, rude, weird, a jerk and on and on. When they get to know us, they find us very perceptive, intuitive, intelligent, and they appreciate our honesty, integrity and loyalty and how we help them to understand themselves and the world around them. We enjoy these interactions with the 'others' but somehow still feel a sense of separation or incompleteness and wearing a Steelers jersey isn't going to change that. Neither is joining some stupid online forum. Or is it? We actually have found other people who slice the onion the same way, and that's not such a bad think. We have found people who can read this post and actually know what I'm talking about. I'll tell you a little story now. My wife died earlier this year after a lifetime of illness. It was brutal what she endured and I could never have done it. But now I'm 38, single, no kids (yet!), make good money and I'm a good looking guy and have my life pretty well in order (for an INTP) and so I've been looking on these dating websites at the profiles of the women around here and they all just look simply ridiculous to me. They keep talking about which vertical slice of onion they are and which one they are looking for but that is meaningless to me. So I look at how they write the profile instead of what they write in it. The whole dating process is really irritating. I would much rather spend a week or two scouring the internet, researching, and then buy my new wife on eBay and live happily ever after. Or maybe I'll walk up to some random woman on the street and tap her on the shoulder and say, "tag, you're it. Now come along with me." In the meantime, I'll just check in on this forum every so often just to know that I am sane.

Does anyone relate to any of this or see things in a different way?
 

Kuu

>>Loading
Local time
Today 3:43 PM
Joined
Jun 7, 2008
Messages
3,446
---
Location
The wired
I'd add 3. Huge blocks of text

This INTP forum is not about belonging. Most people do feel relieved to find others similar to themselves, but that is not the reason they stay. The INTP forum is more like a corporation.
With just your money, you can't do much. But if a group of people with a common goal get together, greater things can be accomplished. Here, we share intellectual capital. Most people cannot do that... so the forum fills that niche.
 

fullerene

Prolific Member
Local time
Today 4:43 PM
Joined
Jul 16, 2008
Messages
2,156
---
mm... well, if I had to speculate, I'd say I think you're (probably subconsciously) looking for people to be associating themselves with some group. I can really only speak for myself... so that's what I'll do. Most of the conversation you have with people out in the world is meaningless... and it makes me sad. Ok, so some conversation on forums is meaningless too... but if you glance through the posts you'll see what I mean by saying it's different than most normal small talk. For people who want to swap ideas... you can do it (mainly in the science, faith, philosophy section). For people who want to ask questions and find out things about people that anyone you meet would look at you crazy if you try to ask, you can do it (mainly all those threads on how you view feelings and, to use yourself as an example, "why are you all here?" Basically the "why are you the way you are" questions, without the risk of sounding like you're insulting someone, as I'm so prone to).

I don't think it's so much a place or group to identify yourself with as it is a place where you can assume that most people also follow their own interests, and listen to strong ideas rather than strong speeches or strong people, based on what the mbti test says they're prone to do.

It's not that there aren't people to talk to... there are. It's just that interaction with them makes me sad, and a little lonely. I just spent two days with some people who were all loose friends with each other, and instead of getting to know each other personally at all (which I did push for for a little), it was two days of the latest news on what other loose friends had been doing. Eventually I just have to go "ok... thoughts need to get out of my head. Let's see what other people with minds full of thoughts are talking about."

I think there's also an inherant value to being forced to type out your thoughts. Have you ever found that you can't even explain your "3D world" to people around you at conversation speed? I know I get that every so often (not always... but at least when someone asks me about something particularly rich). Some philosopher... or theologian... or someone somewhere I know said that everyone should write, because it forces precision and organization in your thoughts. I don't think it's the lack of time or our richness of ideas that prevents us from communicating ideas to people... I think it's an inherant lack of organization (aka intuition). I understand things... but writing them forces me to clarify them so that it's more "on the tip of my toungue" and understandable when someone actually asks.
 

Dissident

Prolific Member
Local time
Today 6:43 PM
Joined
Apr 29, 2008
Messages
1,415
---
Location
Way south.

Agent Intellect

Absurd Anti-hero.
Local time
Today 4:43 PM
Joined
Jul 28, 2008
Messages
4,113
---
Location
Michigan
i'm going to admit that my own personal reason for liking this website is purely selfish. i enjoy exploring the psychology and beliefs of other people, but i enjoy exploring my own psychology and challenging my own beliefs even more. to me, personally, i love getting into passionate debates with people and having to argue my side, have someone else question it and challenge me to think about why i think and believe like i do. that may be why other people are here too, but i can't really speak for them. plus, i think deep down, subconsciously, even the biggest "loner" wants to fit in, even if its with other "loners".
 

Jules

Guest
Local time
Today 10:43 PM
Joined
Jul 3, 2008
Messages
284
---
I'm actually here just to analyze all you people ;)
Aren't you just saying that people are simply different, and that perhaps a majority of the population has roughly the same convictions and views on life, which very much differs from most, if not all, intp's?
A sense of separation is different than incompleteness. Perhaps one enhances the other, but they're not the same. My 'arrogant' self would say that the separation is obvious, but the incompleteness lies on the other end. You can't discuss the ocean with a well frog-he's limited by the space he lives in.* At least you can discuss the ocean on this forum, I think.

btw, are you serious about this mail order bride thing? Wouldn't that make any prospect bride too predictable to be interesting long enough for an intp?

* The books of Chuang Tzu
 

Ermine

is watching and taking notes
Local time
Today 2:43 PM
Joined
Dec 24, 2007
Messages
2,871
---
Location
casually playing guitar in my mental arena
Sorry, you really need to indent more. I couldn't read everything you wrote because I couldn't keep my eyes focused.

Anyway, I don't come here to belong to anything. I just come here to explore everyone's minds here and satisfy my need for intelligent conversation. Same reasons as Agent Intellect.
 

loveofreason

echoes through time
Local time
Today 10:43 AM
Joined
Sep 8, 2007
Messages
5,492
---
I think there's a question hidden in all that text... something along the lines of "Is it OK to want to belong?"

Or maybe "Will you guys accept me if I make it clear I disdain the concept of belonging so I can't possibly be hurt when I get rejected?" Because you've lost someone and you're looking. And you chose to share that with a whole (anonymous) group of strangers, all of your type - the least threatening bunch you could find, and still being so vulnerable made a gauche, awkward, self-conscious introduction, with a preplanned escape if it all went wrong.

So, is it OK to want to belong? I think so. (Mind you my nervous system screams out differently.) In this arena 'belonging' means being understood, not being uniform. Most all of us would be familiar with chronic alienation. There's no shame in wanting something a little warmer.
 

Jordan~

Prolific Member
Local time
Today 9:43 PM
Joined
Jun 4, 2008
Messages
1,964
---
Location
Dundee, Scotland
I, for one, joined out of interest - the same reason for which I do most things.
 

Jesin

Prolific Member
Local time
Today 4:43 PM
Joined
May 2, 2008
Messages
2,036
---
In this arena 'belonging' means being understood, not being uniform. Most all of us would be familiar with chronic alienation. There's no shame in wanting something a little warmer.

That ^ yes.
 

Agent Intellect

Absurd Anti-hero.
Local time
Today 4:43 PM
Joined
Jul 28, 2008
Messages
4,113
---
Location
Michigan
So, is it OK to want to belong? I think so. (Mind you my nervous system screams out differently.) In this arena 'belonging' means being understood, not being uniform. Most all of us would be familiar with chronic alienation. There's no shame in wanting something a little warmer.


^couldn't have said it better myself
 

Vrecknidj

Prolific Member
Local time
Today 4:43 PM
Joined
Nov 21, 2007
Messages
2,196
---
Location
Michigan/Indiana, USA
I'm not here to belong. I find many of the conversations interesting, and that's often enough for me.

On occasion, I think I can help someone, and that's a bonus.

That said, I don't mind belonging. It's just not an issue for me.

Dave
 

Wisp

The Soft Rational
Local time
Today 4:43 PM
Joined
Jan 4, 2008
Messages
1,291
---
Location
East Coast of USA
As usual LoR expands upon her forte and says it all...
 

grrreg

Member
Local time
Today 4:43 PM
Joined
Aug 1, 2008
Messages
53
---
Location
NYC
wait , isn't this the gay-chemist-exhibitionist-in-the-greater-new-york-area-prone-to-sarcasm-cotinuum? NO? !! I want my money back.

yes, LoR really says it well.

My advice, make sure your grief is completely over before you begin dating again.
I'm very sorry for what happened.

Internet dating is crap in general. Go out with some associates or not and stare someone down until she talks to you. Or runs. Or calls the police. I usually meet the best people to date totally randomly. But it's like Joan Rivers says , 'you gotta look good look good look good' . So feel free to put that Steelers jacket on if it gets you noticed. Getting noticed is step one. Dazzle with quirky intellect , step 2.

good luck!
 

Oblivious

Is Kredit to Team!!
Local time
Tomorrow 5:43 AM
Joined
Apr 30, 2008
Messages
1,266
---
Location
Purgatory with the cool kids
"tag, you're it. Now come along with me."

You know, this might actually work.

Anyway, one of the reasons we may be here is that we require a form of validation for the thoughts that we share. I came here to validate my own thoughts and, if possible, refine them. It is quite rare to ever find a person who think on the same wavelength as we do, so to find a group of people who think in such a similar fashion is quite exciting at first.

We may know objectively that the number of people who believe in a certain idea is not proportional to its validity. However in practice, psychological elements apply especially since our thought processes are theoretical in nature. We depend on many people and things in order to survive in society, so who are we to question popular thinking?

I, and I believe many others on this forum, do not buy that. All of us consciously or otherwise have a structure of collective knowledge within us where we do not tolerate contradictions and irregularities, weaknesses that would collapse this 'Babel Tower' we have erected within us. We are natural perceivers, however I believe that the judgement that many of us are able to utilise come our efforts to ensure the integrity of this Tower.

In our efforts to ensure the consistency and strength of our thoughts, we have sought to filter only the purest truths from the sea of knowledge and lies swimming around us, but at cost to the façade society has thrown up around itself to grease its way to stability. In our efforts to maintain our individual intellectual clarity and consistency we have given up unconditional trust in popular thought and have accepted a measure of loneliness in cost.

This forum means that we do not need to.
 

Linsejko

Ghost of עמק רפאים.
Local time
Today 3:43 PM
Joined
Mar 26, 2008
Messages
603
---
Location
In the center of the world. (As opposed to the ear
Ha, I'm lazier about reading than I used to be. The OP and the last post, I didn't really bother to read the entirety of.

Not having paragraphs is not acceptable... I read through a WOT somewhere else on this forum once, but it had paragraph breaks. Without that, not worth the effort.

I, also, joined for interest. I honestly do not feel a sense of 'belonging', though I wouldn't have a problem with that if I did. I do enjoy the chance to stretch some philisophical/semantic/intellectual that I don't otherwise find company that makes it worth the effort to do so, and find some interesting topics to think about occasionally in the process.

Also, a few interesting folks maintain my interest in the same way any ol' blogger might.

.L
 

cleanyourfeet

Redshirt
Local time
Today 9:43 PM
Joined
Aug 29, 2008
Messages
1
---
i like what you said, i like how you said it, i understood it, i agree

i am separate from all other humans, they categorize themselves in ways i find strange, i categorize myself by how i think, what i know, maybe it is because of my myers-briggs type, maybe the other ones like me think the same way

but they dont, they dont all think the same way

being here makes me self-conscious about how i think
 

Wisp

The Soft Rational
Local time
Today 4:43 PM
Joined
Jan 4, 2008
Messages
1,291
---
Location
East Coast of USA
Lin! It's been a while. Welcome back. =)
 

rocky00753

Redshirt
Local time
Today 9:43 PM
Joined
Jun 12, 2008
Messages
14
---
Unlike most people here, I am here because I feel the need to belong somewhere.
I have never belonged anywhere. I have no real friends. I did the test, and found this board.
Suddenly there were a whole lot of people I could relate to. People going through the same things that I am. This place helps me deal with my problems and emotions in a rational way.
For no apparent reason, it cheers me up when I feel low.
 

eudemonia

still searching
Local time
Today 9:43 PM
Joined
Aug 25, 2008
Messages
1,095
---
Location
UK
I would just like to share something my 15 year old daughter said to me today. "Mum" she said, "since you've been on this forum, you've been much jollier and younger". So I asked my 13 year old son if he had noticed a difference. "Yeah, too right" he said. "You seem much younger and you make more jokes". Who needs botox?:D
 

Agent Intellect

Absurd Anti-hero.
Local time
Today 4:43 PM
Joined
Jul 28, 2008
Messages
4,113
---
Location
Michigan
I would just like to share something my 15 year old daughter said to me today. "Mum" she said, "since you've been on this forum, you've been much jollier and younger". So I asked my 13 year old son if he had noticed a difference. "Yeah, too right" he said. "You seem much younger and you make more jokes". Who needs botox?:D

i must not be trying hard enough to suck the joy of life out of you!
 

Jennywocky

Creepy Clown Chick
Local time
Today 4:43 PM
Joined
Sep 25, 2008
Messages
10,739
---
Location
Charn
I would just like to share something my 15 year old daughter said to me today. "Mum" she said, "since you've been on this forum, you've been much jollier and younger". So I asked my 13 year old son if he had noticed a difference. "Yeah, too right" he said. "You seem much younger and you make more jokes". Who needs botox?:D

ha ha, good for you, hon. *hug*

If only we could bottle the place and sell it, huh? :D
 

Sylzarra

Member
Local time
Today 9:43 PM
Joined
Oct 25, 2008
Messages
52
---
Location
The 11th dimension
Hum well i came here cause I was tired of dealing with people of different types and I did feel a bit alone... I figured out that my feeling of being alone was silly and unfounded afterward though. However I stay because I simply enjoy reading all the things people have to say on here. Most of the ideas are new to me and make me think. I can rarely condense my ideas to make a coherent post so most of the times I end up keeping the pondering to my self. But I still enjoy listening immensely.
 

FusionKnight

It's not my fault!
Local time
Today 3:43 PM
Joined
Aug 20, 2008
Messages
1,398
---
Location
MN, USA
ha ha, good for you, hon. *hug*

If only we could bottle the place and sell it, huh? :D

We could sell jars of pickled INTPness... it'd probably go over well down south... :eek:

*Run Away!*
 

Ogion

Paladin of Patience
Local time
Today 10:43 PM
Joined
Jun 23, 2008
Messages
2,305
---
Location
Germany
I knew it! This forum is just a large trap to get (whateve'd) INTPnesses from us!!!11!!

Get out :eek::phear::eek::phear:

;)

Ogion
 

sagewolf

Badass Longcat
Local time
Today 4:43 PM
Joined
Oct 27, 2008
Messages
1,374
---
Location
Lost, after wandering irresponsibly away from the
I found the forum and liked the idea of joining. It wasn't that i wanted to belong (I decided that sucked a long time ago, and I have a few friends in the real world anyway that I can get on well with) but that I wanted to join in with the discussions. Whenever I try to start a debate with someone in real life it ends disastrously. My mom thinks I'm questioning her inborn superior knowledge (I have never been able to convince her this is not the case; she treats me like an idiot anyway), my dad just... doesn't talk, and my friends don't get it at all. They think I'm arguing and move on quickly. Teachers have been my best bet so far, but it's hard to find them outside of class, and there are always a load of people in class, which makes me too self-conscious to say anything. It's nice to be part of a community that knows the difference between an argument and a hostile argument.

That said, you all know so much more than me! I feel like a self-important dolt if I post any of my nonsense. :(
 

NoID10ts

aka Noddy
Local time
Today 3:43 PM
Joined
Jul 14, 2008
Messages
4,541
---
Location
Houston, TX
That said, you all know so much more than me! I feel like a self-important dolt if I post any of my nonsense. :(

Any time you think that what you have to offer is nonsense, read though some of my posts and it will make you feel better. I pride myself on posting more nonsense, with greater frequency than anyone else here. I really have a commitment to quality nonsense on this forum. In fact, if you are really unsure, juxatapose your post near one of mine and you will look like Einstein in comparison! it's a public service really.

:D
 

Ogion

Paladin of Patience
Local time
Today 10:43 PM
Joined
Jun 23, 2008
Messages
2,305
---
Location
Germany
And, boy, you do deliver quality...:D

Ogion
 

Agent Intellect

Absurd Anti-hero.
Local time
Today 4:43 PM
Joined
Jul 28, 2008
Messages
4,113
---
Location
Michigan
I even offer a money back guarantee on all my nonsense. If you aren't completely satisfied I will refund your money, no questions asked!

must..... resist..... derailing thread.....



you satisfy my INTPness just fine!



...oh God, i need help.
 

Jesin

Prolific Member
Local time
Today 4:43 PM
Joined
May 2, 2008
Messages
2,036
---
Any time you think that what you have to offer is nonsense, read though some of my posts and it will make you feel better. I pride myself on posting more nonsense, with greater frequency than anyone else here. I really have a commitment to quality nonsense on this forum. In fact, if you are really unsure, juxatapose your post near one of mine and you will look like Einstein in comparison! it's a public service really.

:D

That is almost exactly what was described here:
YouTube- Monty Python - Village Idiots
 

sagewolf

Badass Longcat
Local time
Today 4:43 PM
Joined
Oct 27, 2008
Messages
1,374
---
Location
Lost, after wandering irresponsibly away from the
...oh God, i need help.

I believe, as far as we go, that goes without saying. :D But who can help us? Who is brave enough?

I love Monty Python. I hate my internet connection. It loads for ten seconds, and plays for three. ... Not even the Python crew is worth it.

@NoId10ts
Any time you think that what you have to offer is nonsense, read though some of my posts and it will make you feel better. I pride myself on posting more nonsense, with greater frequency than anyone else here. I really have a commitment to quality nonsense on this forum. In fact, if you are really unsure, juxatapose your post near one of mine and you will look like Einstein in comparison! it's a public service really.

Thanks! I feel like I got conscripted into that same service, though... :rolleyes:
 

Jesin

Prolific Member
Local time
Today 4:43 PM
Joined
May 2, 2008
Messages
2,036
---
I love Monty Python. I hate my internet connection. It loads for ten seconds, and plays for three.

What you do about this is you open the page, pause the video, and then browse in another tab while you wait for it to load. (Yes, Youtube videos continue to download while they're paused.) Watch it once it's done loading.
 

sagewolf

Badass Longcat
Local time
Today 4:43 PM
Joined
Oct 27, 2008
Messages
1,374
---
Location
Lost, after wandering irresponsibly away from the
Thank you for that, Jesin!
 
Last edited by a moderator:

INTPINFP

Active Member
Local time
Today 9:43 PM
Joined
Oct 27, 2008
Messages
285
---
Location
surburbs
88sansui, the thing about hatred is, if you're not careful, in certain scenarios, you'll become the thing you hate.
 

sagewolf

Badass Longcat
Local time
Today 4:43 PM
Joined
Oct 27, 2008
Messages
1,374
---
Location
Lost, after wandering irresponsibly away from the
(Yep: he's making us all happy by joking, see? What a first-class Forum Idiot! Accept your handful of mud and kick in the head with pride! *splat-boot*)

On a side note that is really the main note, I just realised something: since I joined the forum and started taking part in the discussions, I've been thinking more-- analyzing things and constructing arguments to support the things that I think about... anything that comes to mind... off the wall, without any stimulation whatsoever. I think that's a good thing. I like that I'm thinking more since I joined.

I am so staying here.
 

EloquentBohemian

MysticDragon
Local time
Today 4:43 PM
Joined
Oct 4, 2008
Messages
1,386
---
Location
Ottawa, Canada
Okay NoID10ts, ya gots da job!:D
On a side note that is really the main note, I just realised something: since I joined the forum and started taking part in the discussions, I've been thinking more-- analyzing things and constructing arguments to support the things that I think about... anything that comes to mind... off the wall, without any stimulation whatsoever. I think that's a good thing. I like that I'm thinking more since I joined.
Ha!:) I was just thinking the same thing last night while posting. This Forum is great! Intelligent individuals. INTPness. And its own resident Village NoID10ts.:D What more could one ask.

I am so staying here.
Yup .....puts feet up on ottoman while sinking into the comfy chair sipping 'nother coffee.
 

NoID10ts

aka Noddy
Local time
Today 3:43 PM
Joined
Jul 14, 2008
Messages
4,541
---
Location
Houston, TX
So should I have the mods change my name from NoID10ts to just ID10t?

I'm glad I serve a purpose here. It warms the cockles of my heart!

:rolleyes: <------Ehh! This shifty eyed guy is back! How can I report him?!
 

EloquentBohemian

MysticDragon
Local time
Today 4:43 PM
Joined
Oct 4, 2008
Messages
1,386
---
Location
Ottawa, Canada
It warms the INTPness of your heart?:D
 

EloquentBohemian

MysticDragon
Local time
Today 4:43 PM
Joined
Oct 4, 2008
Messages
1,386
---
Location
Ottawa, Canada
...and such a swell job you do of it!:D
 
Top Bottom