• OK, it's on.
  • Please note that many, many Email Addresses used for spam, are not accepted at registration. Select a respectable Free email.
  • Done now. Domine miserere nobis.

MBTIland?

Da Blob

Banned
Local time
Yesterday 6:02 PM
Joined
Dec 19, 2008
Messages
5,926
---
Location
Oklahoma
I do not how how many of you have read Abbot's book, Flatland or have seen the movie, but I was struck by the thought "could a similar story be told about the dimensions of personality?"
If so, what would be the plot line?
How could the personality dimensions be presented visually?
Etc.

YouTube - Flatland: The Movie - Official Trailer

BTW there are some interesting segments in 'related videos'
 

Inappropriate Behavior

is peeing on the carpet
Local time
Yesterday 7:02 PM
Joined
Sep 21, 2008
Messages
3,795
---
Location
Behind you, kicking you in the ass
I heard of the book once and forgot thus I never read it. I looked for the dvd on Netflix and was disappointed not to find it. It looks interesting.
 

Artifice Orisit

Guest
BTW there are some interesting segments in 'related videos'
"THE DOT and THE LINE: a romance in lower mathematics" was good, but I can't help thinking that the Line should have left the Dot as a matter of personal standards.

Now back to the main point, what would be the point of such a story?
Perhaps if you had 16 individual characters, each being a rather extreme rendition of the MBTI type they're representing... well the ending would be realization that all people are the same at some deep/innate level, and that the 16 types are just 16 different paths to the same enlightenment. There also needs to be a source of conflict, not necessarily physical conflict, just some sort of problem that needs to be overcome. Going by some old standards, the pursuit of love/happiness/peace could be the source of conflict and our 16 protagonists must overcome their inner demons (fear, hate, insecurity, spite, pride, greed, lust, envy, etc...).

Considering the sheer number of protagonists and the personal nature of their antagonists, it would probably be more suitable to write 16 individual stories occurring along the same time-line, and have the protagonist’s paths cross for time-to-time; in effect something like a single massive story told from 16 perspectives.

The setting could be a modern city, physically the same location for all 16 protagonists by seen differently by their different perspectives; this could be a major focal point of the story, how they're all walking exactly the same streets, but mentally living in completely different worlds.
 

Da Blob

Banned
Local time
Yesterday 6:02 PM
Joined
Dec 19, 2008
Messages
5,926
---
Location
Oklahoma
cool! I had not thought of the possibility of a real world setting using human actors. That could be a very very good movie if done right.

I was thinking more along the lines of a cartoon with a beginning like
"Long ago the Kingdom of personality was divided into eight distinct two-dimensional realms whose shallow citizens each exhibited only one personality trait per district...
The plot would develop because of a confused stork that delivered the wrong babies to the wrong district. One E in the district of I, One S in the district of I etc.
There would be opportunity for conversations and debates involving these Odd balls. Of course they (the 8) would be banished eventually and begin a classical quest...

Perhaps the happy ending after suitable stress and conflict would be the creation of two new beings each with four traits (Adam and Eve types)
 

Anthile

Steel marks flesh
Local time
Today 1:02 AM
Joined
Jan 10, 2009
Messages
3,987
---
Can there be mecha? Please? :angel:


Also, I think there should be a major conflict. Like the clans of introverted functions wage war against the united states of extroverted functions in the holy land of Amygdala.
But then the unthinkable happens and a young introverted function and another young extroverted function fall in love with each other!

:confused:
 

Da Blob

Banned
Local time
Yesterday 6:02 PM
Joined
Dec 19, 2008
Messages
5,926
---
Location
Oklahoma
Can there be mecha? Please? :angel:


Also, I think there should be a major conflict. Like the clans of introverted functions wage war against the united states of extroverted functions in the holy land of Amygdala.
But then the unthinkable happens and a young introverted function and another young extroverted function fall in love with each other!

:confused:
Mencha ...? Hell, why not...
as long as the lovers are named Romeo and Juliette
 
Local time
Yesterday 7:02 PM
Joined
Aug 12, 2009
Messages
746
---
Location
metro Detroit area
perhaps some sort of gang wars?
 

Anthile

Steel marks flesh
Local time
Today 1:02 AM
Joined
Jan 10, 2009
Messages
3,987
---
The mecha are for the male demography and the (shallow) love interest for the female demography. After that we can talk about art and meaning. Sadly, that's how making films works nowadays.


Alternatives for male demography:

-blowing stuff up
-sex with barely known women
-machine guns
-torture scenes
-cars
-jet fights
-boobies
-martial arts
 

Da Blob

Banned
Local time
Yesterday 6:02 PM
Joined
Dec 19, 2008
Messages
5,926
---
Location
Oklahoma
The mecha are for the male demography and the (shallow) love interest for the female demography. After that we can talk about art and meaning. Sadly, that's how making films works nowadays.


Alternatives for male demography:

-blowing stuff up
-sex with barely known women
-machine guns
-torture scenes
-cars
-jet fights
-boobies
-martial arts
Truth to be financially successful we must be both puerile and romantic. I was thinking that we needed a multi-level ambiguous plot anyway.
One level for those who are familiar with MBTI with lots of 'insider' jokes
then another level for the GP
and perhaps even a third level
Gang wars between cyborgs might work - has anyone thought how personality might play a role in the choice of cybernetic enhancements and accessories?


However, I just can't get the image of the scenario of the War between the clans out of mind LOL!
The E's would be dancing around making a lot of noise and boasting. The I army would just be sitting there musing. However, at a single blast of a trumpet, the I's would look each other in the eye, nod and then go utterly kick the shit out of the E's without saying a word or making a noise...


EDIT: afterthoughts - What would ultimate would be a setting in a Jungian Universe, with amina, animus, shadows, dreams etc.
MBTI Superheroes and villiians?
 

Artifice Orisit

Guest
Gang wars between cyborgs might work - has anyone thought how personality might play a role in the choice of cybernetic enhancements and accessories?
...um, gee I dunno, now let me think about it for a sec... :rolleyes:

EDIT: afterthoughts - What would ultimate would be a setting in a Jungian Universe, with amina, animus, shadows, dreams etc.
MBTI Superheroes and villiians?
Do the full symbolic (mind-screw) "journey to the centre of the mind" type of thing?
That's alway's interesting... but where's the conflict? and how are you going to plausibly get the 16 types into the one mind-space?

Don't forget there are "villain types" or "hero types", sure stereotypically INTPs/INTJs get given such a role, but that doesn’t mean we need to follow set conventions.

I was thinking more along the lines of a cartoon with a beginning like
"Long ago the Kingdom of personality was divided into eight distinct two-dimensional realms whose shallow citizens each exhibited only one personality trait per district...
The plot would develop because of a confused stork that delivered the wrong babies to the wrong district. One E in the district of I, One S in the district of I etc.
There would be opportunity for conversations and debates involving these Odd balls. Of course they (the 8) would be banished eventually and begin a classical quest...
I highly doubt anyone could make compelling characters out of the individual MBTI traits, e.g. what's the outwardly noticeable difference between a "N" and a "S"?

Even just having a "flat" (little development of character) INTP is going to be difficult, even the slightest things can become glowing neon signs implying inner complexity beyond the personality classification of INTP, thereby alienating all INTPs that can't directly relate to that aspect of that character.
 

Cavallier

Oh damn.
Local time
Yesterday 4:02 PM
Joined
Aug 23, 2009
Messages
3,639
---
This sounds oddly like "Bladerunner".

Crazy world with bright lights and sex everywhere you turn. Obviously some weird hyper extroverted E-topia :eek:!

Then the introverts...ahem...I mean androids are being enslaved by all the Es. Plus, remember the scene where Harrison Ford has to teach Rachel how to be affectionate? Sounds like an INTP to me.

Plus you get the whole light and dark, shadows, and high/low ground imagery you could go all metaphorical with.

Oh, and on a side note am I the only one who thinks Rick Deckard is a poorly made anagram?
 

GarmGarf

Active Member
Local time
Today 12:02 AM
Joined
Dec 15, 2008
Messages
223
---
Location
Ireland (Dublin)
Gang wars between cyborgs might work - has anyone thought how personality might play a role in the choice of cybernetic enhancements and accessories?

Thinkers may wish to install the "pure objective mind" mental augmentation.
 

Causeless

Active Member
Local time
Yesterday 7:02 PM
Joined
Aug 31, 2009
Messages
343
---
I doubt you could even HAVE an INTP cyborg.

I think we'd just get carried away and replace everything. :rolleyes::D
 
Top Bottom