• OK, it's on.
  • Please note that many, many Email Addresses used for spam, are not accepted at registration. Select a respectable Free email.
  • Done now. Domine miserere nobis.

INTJ or INTP: How did you know?

Rebis

Blessed are the hearts that can bend
Local time
Today 11:57 AM
Joined
Oct 6, 2019
Messages
1,669
---
Location
Ireland
If you're interested, you can find a lot of J/P input from me in a two-post roundup at Typology Central that starts here.

I've seen dozens of posts about the difference while I knew the applications of the fundamental difference. Your post was incredible, if everyone read that we would never have a loop of the topic again. If this was reddit that'd be pinned to the top. Best post in recent memory.
 

scorpiomover

The little professor
Local time
Today 11:57 AM
Joined
May 3, 2011
Messages
3,383
---
How did you know you were INTJ versus INTP, or how did you know you were INTP versus INTJ?
Easy.

When I was a kid, a teen and a young man, and I did those personality tests, I'd always come out as "overly logical". It became a running joke with my flate-mates in uni.

I joined INTJ forum and here. On INTJ forum, it was very, very clear that I wasn't like the INTJs, and drove them crazy because they couldn't understand how I thought.

One day, INTJ forum was down. I came across this forum and the thread "You know you're an INTP when..." I started reading. I got through 25 pages, so 625 posts. I did ALL of the things posted bar 3 things.

I'm starting to see that I'm not wrong for being myself.
No-one is.

So, I've been reflecting a lot. I'm still trying to figure out whether or not I'm definitively INTJ, but I'm almost sure that I am.
I suspected something was off, because INTPs aren't usually as driven for success as you seem to be.

I suggest you spend a bit of time reading the thread here entitled "You know you're an INTP when..." INTJs don't do any of that stuff, not the ways those INTPs did them (INTJs are also good at solving problems, but NOT the way that INTPs do).

I might still be INTP, I've identified with it for so long, and I like some people here. Yet as I developed, everything I've done independently of ESFJ influence was very ENTJ. I never needed anyone to get things done,
If you notice, INTPs often write about things that they have done, in a manner that sounds casual, as if it was nothing.

But if you examine the task/problem they are mentioning, and consider it objectively, such as if it was attempted by a regular person, would be considered extremely difficult, and for someone with their personal issues, should be almost impossible.

INTPs also don't seem to mention a whole variety of things that the rest of the world complains about endlessly as being a major problem, as if for them, it's not a problem at all.

So don't mistake form of expression as being synonymous with content.

but because I was highly regarded for my knowledge base I literally influenced the teams I managed from basic to advanced knowledge of X.
A poster on INTJf pointed out that when it comes to typing yourself, people are likely to fall for cognitive bias and superiority bias, and so it's better to look at the negatives of your type.

ENTJs are generally valued for their ability to manage teams, and to delegate optimally, because they are very good at identifying the strengths and weaknesses of individual team members and assign tasks accordingly.

ENTJs are NOT normally valued for their technical knowledge, precisely because technical knowledge can be delegated, and so spending time influencing teams because of technical knowledge can be a detraction from the much more influential tasks of managing and delegating optimally. So even if they have a great technical knowledge, it can be a severe disadvantage and is often best kept unmentioned.

INTPs generally are valued for their expertise and knowledge. INTPs tend to focus on logic. Think of how much of society and technology, both now and in human history, has been developed through logic. Even when they are good managers, their expertise is often on a level that way beyond anything that the other employees have, that merely being around the INTP makes the other employees reason far better and become far more efficient and competent than ever before.

One reason that you find INTJs often complaining about INTP work colleagues, and yet never seem to say that they tried to get the INTP transferred to a different team.

It would seem that an ESTJ would just try and displace the entire team at a second's notice of changes in quarterly earnings, making false correlations due to lack of analysis. Sure, blame the team, not the holes in the business model (sarcasm). I saw underneath and beyond that kind of short term movement.
That sounds like stereotypical put-downs that you see all over the internet. It's not really much of an objective assessment of the things that ESTJs would be good at, is it?

I mean, do you REALLY need an ENTJ to deal with most of the day-to-day stuff that happens in a Walmart superstore? Most of that stuff is routine. Wouldn't all the routine stuff just bore an ENTJ to distraction?

And for that reason I really don't much identify with ENTJs as I'm very much not "commanding" by nature and I don't actually care about money the way the average ENTJs typically do in the way where it seems to be defining of their strengths.
IME, ENTJs and ENFJs seem to have this attitude where if they are in the room, they act as if they are in charge of everyone else, even when they are not.

It's an affectation that serves them well when there's a task to be done by the group, and no-one is stepping up.

So, the only thing left seems to be INTJ.

There is close to nothing in terms of information on INTJ women that helps me put the pieces together in a clear way. Anyone who writes about INTJ seems to rarely be INTJ themselves, which makes things even harder to trust validity.
I've had a lot of experiences with INTJs, both online and IRL.

If you want to know INTJs, spend a few months debating them, on an INTJ forum, or even just debating them here. After a few months, you'll notice that they tend to rely on the same strategies repeatedly. Different INTJs sometimes use different strategies. But the overall list of strategies for INTJs in general is extremely consistent. Also, the general strategies of responses for a particular INTJ tends to be extremely consistent.

People just expect me to fit this harshly delineated mold.

So, yeah, honestly I feel truly alone.

I don't even fit the stereotype of INTJs, but, eh, I think @washti threw me off since when I first joined because his first contact with me was so odd to me beyond my comprehension lol.

I guess I can settle with "burnt out INTJ" + "over-ambitious INTP" for now.
I don't spend a lot of time here, because if you notice, I'm not like most INTPs either, and neither are my posts.
 

Rebis

Blessed are the hearts that can bend
Local time
Today 11:57 AM
Joined
Oct 6, 2019
Messages
1,669
---
Location
Ireland
You're an INTP that just executes on your prospects, that's all.

If you require more points I'll do it after work.
 

Kormak

The IT barbarian - eNTP - 6w7-4-8 so/sx
Local time
Today 1:57 PM
Joined
Sep 18, 2019
Messages
513
---
Location
Your mother's basement
If you want to know INTJs, spend a few months debating them, on an INTJ forum, or even just debating them here. After a few months, you'll notice that they tend to rely on the same strategies repeatedly. Different INTJs sometimes use different strategies. But the overall list of strategies for INTJs in general is extremely consistent. Also, the general strategies of responses for a particular INTJ tends to be extremely consistent.

Damn, that sounds rather boring. I can't even read a book twice or play a videogame twice. e_e a friend of mine from Scotland invited me to play Path of Exile once... I gave up after lvl 40, the grind got to me. Recently classic wow released, everyone was hyped... I tried... but man its so damn boring now that I know I did it be4... it just sucks the life out of the entire experience.

On topic....

How can one be confused about mbti j-P dichotomy? Its very simple :/ perceivers are highly adaptable and only make rough plans at the best.

Example: I got called through a friend this friday to a company to fix their internal network, the modem died, the ISP came, changed it, changed some stuff and now they coulldn't acess programs running on their servers, the fingerprint scanners and a bunch of other crap wasn't working anymore.

^^; did I make plans, ask for more details, make a shedule or any of that? NOPE

I grabbed the laptop, went there after work and fixed their mess, got payed a fat sum of money. Why they don't have an IT guy beats the hell out of me. Its usually what I do, I figure things out and improvise on the fly. Its what perceivers do, we adapt and overcome.
 

Rebis

Blessed are the hearts that can bend
Local time
Today 11:57 AM
Joined
Oct 6, 2019
Messages
1,669
---
Location
Ireland
If you want to know INTJs, spend a few months debating them, on an INTJ forum, or even just debating them here. After a few months, you'll notice that they tend to rely on the same strategies repeatedly. Different INTJs sometimes use different strategies. But the overall list of strategies for INTJs in general is extremely consistent. Also, the general strategies of responses for a particular INTJ tends to be extremely consistent.

Damn, that sounds rather boring. I can't even read a book twice or play a videogame twice. e_e a friend of mine from Scotland invited me to play Path of Exile once... I gave up after lvl 40, the grind got to me. Recently classic wow released, everyone was hyped... I tried... but man its so damn boring now that I know I did it be4... it just sucks the life out of the entire experience.

On topic....

How can one be confused about mbti j-P dichotomy? Its very simple :/ perceivers are highly adaptable and only make rough plans at the best.

Example: I got called through a friend this friday to a company to fix their internal network, the modem died, the ISP came, changed it, changed some stuff and now they coulldn't acess programs running on their servers, the fingerprint scanners and a bunch of other crap wasn't working anymore.

^^; did I make plans, ask for more details, make a shedule or any of that? NOPE

I grabbed the laptop, went there after work and fixed their mess, got payed a fat sum of money. Why they don't have an IT guy beats the hell out of me. Its usually what I do, I figure things out and improvise on the fly. Its what perceivers do, we adapt and overcome.

So what, you got payed a fat sum to essentially change the gateway address through their new modem, different wifi protocols (WEP to WPA2/3) so network packets can be sent/recieved? Suspiciously dumb, what company is this? Given the only variable is a modem I know this should've been the only resolution.
 

Kormak

The IT barbarian - eNTP - 6w7-4-8 so/sx
Local time
Today 1:57 PM
Joined
Sep 18, 2019
Messages
513
---
Location
Your mother's basement
So what, you got payed a fat sum to essentially change the gateway address through their new modem, different wifi protocols (WEP to WPA2/3) so network packets can be sent/recieved? Suspiciously dumb, what company is this? Given the only variable is a modem I know this should've been the only resolution.

XD its a semi-automated factory that produces paper cups lmao. A lot of companies here cut IT costs by not employing people or having ppl from other sectors be responsible for upkeep. I work at an Austrian factory for example (86 ppl), we basically build those giant illuminated signs you see on stadiums, supermarkets, malls, stores and other stuff like gas station pylons. Even here I have 2 other jobs on top of network administration & computer repair:

1. Responsible for legal waste disposal and environmental protection. I get rid of industrial waste and report statistics to the Romanian government / do all the annoying paperwork.

2. Responsible for raw material and tool acquisition for production. I basically order the stuff we make our products out of as well as manage and acquire the tools & machines we use, including IT. e_e some things are externalized so I manage transportation and contact with other companies which basically make this stuff for us.

:/ we used to be 2 ppl, but the other old guy quit. I'm thinking of quitting too. The job is boring AF, I get a raise every year, but its nothing substantial... e_e the worst part is my ESTJ boss, miss second in command nutcase drama queen, miss "Its logical no!?" Hate that bitch..

e_e what.. lol no. I wish it was that simple. Idk, their network is rather old it seems (2011). Over here most ISPs use PPOE, there is a fiberoptics connection to the modem, which then is connected to either a router or in this case another server that runs pfsense. That server died along with the modem (power surge issue? idk), they called the ISP cus no net obviously and they came & bypassed the entire thing, changed the static IPs on the printers and reconnected the workstations to the newly installed router. XD but they had no idea how the internal network layout was, neither does anyone there and the windows database server was ignored for some reason. Ofc the server had a static IP and didn't connect to the new network, the same goes for the fingerprint scanners, other wireless routers, and machines in the production facility. ^^ they have databases running on the windows server for applications they use. Only the internet was running in the main office & they could print. :)) they didn't even know the password or user to the new router. :)))))) I checked the model, got the default PW for it and magic e_e I was in... which was scary cus it meant a random guy with a laptop in the courtyard could get in... the network was not secure at all. (ISP personnel ....smh)

I just checked the IP most things were running on, reconfigured the router, undid what the ISP screwed up and got the database server running, secured the router. O.o curiously they could never get the fingerprint scanners to work be4, e_e but those were on yet another completely different IP.. I just reconfigured them to the new one and everything worked.

When I have time I'll fix the pfsense server, It looks like its just a psu failure. The new router is not good for the amount of data they have running through the network. The raid in the windows server is old af, HDDs as well ^^; I told the boss, but its not my fault they are cheap & dumb.
 

scorpiomover

The little professor
Local time
Today 11:57 AM
Joined
May 3, 2011
Messages
3,383
---
If you want to know INTJs, spend a few months debating them, on an INTJ forum, or even just debating them here. After a few months, you'll notice that they tend to rely on the same strategies repeatedly. Different INTJs sometimes use different strategies. But the overall list of strategies for INTJs in general is extremely consistent. Also, the general strategies of responses for a particular INTJ tends to be extremely consistent.

Damn, that sounds rather boring. I can't even read a book twice or play a videogame twice. e_e a friend of mine from Scotland invited me to play Path of Exile once... I gave up after lvl 40, the grind got to me. Recently classic wow released, everyone was hyped... I tried... but man its so damn boring now that I know I did it be4... it just sucks the life out of the entire experience.

On topic....

How can one be confused about mbti j-P dichotomy? Its very simple :/ perceivers are highly adaptable and only make rough plans at the best.

Example: I got called through a friend this friday to a company to fix their internal network, the modem died, the ISP came, changed it, changed some stuff and now they coulldn't acess programs running on their servers, the fingerprint scanners and a bunch of other crap wasn't working anymore.

^^; did I make plans, ask for more details, make a shedule or any of that? NOPE

I grabbed the laptop, went there after work and fixed their mess, got payed a fat sum of money. Why they don't have an IT guy beats the hell out of me. Its usually what I do, I figure things out and improvise on the fly. Its what perceivers do, we adapt and overcome.
If you'd read the posts of INTJs on INTJ forum, you'd have seen that INTJs regularly claim to be as adaptable and capable as you claimed, particularly in the very area that you talked about here. So being highly adaptable doesn't differentiate Js from Ps.
 

Kormak

The IT barbarian - eNTP - 6w7-4-8 so/sx
Local time
Today 1:57 PM
Joined
Sep 18, 2019
Messages
513
---
Location
Your mother's basement
If you'd read the posts of INTJs on INTJ forum, you'd have seen that INTJs regularly claim to be as adaptable and capable as you claimed, particularly in the very area that you talked about here. So being highly adaptable doesn't differentiate Js from Ps.

Other more complicated methods would involve understanding model A and socionics dichotomies. It is as surefire as it gets.

This calculator can be used to narrow down options. It is my personal opinion based on experience, that if one dichotomy doesn't fit, the type is wrong: http://zhilkin.com/socio/en/

Both INTP and INTJ however are farsighted, and not carefree: https://junglove.net/carefree-vs-farsighted/

Here is a good breakdown of ENTP vvs INTP for example: https://junglove.net/type-vs-type-entp-or-intp/
 

scorpiomover

The little professor
Local time
Today 11:57 AM
Joined
May 3, 2011
Messages
3,383
---
Other more complicated methods would involve understanding model A and socionics dichotomies. It is as surefire as it gets.

This calculator can be used to narrow down options. It is my personal opinion based on experience, that if one dichotomy doesn't fit, the type is wrong: http://zhilkin.com/socio/en/

Both INTP and INTJ however are farsighted, and not carefree: https://junglove.net/carefree-vs-farsighted/

Here is a good breakdown of ENTP vvs INTP for example: https://junglove.net/type-vs-type-entp-or-intp/
I can see how that might give you an idea of how to understand the E/I dichotomy. But since you've only said that when it comes to the J/P dichotomy, INTs are the same in terms of farsighted v carefree, it seems like you're NOT addressing this, which is the OP's problem:

How can one be confused about mbti j-P dichotomy?
 

Kormak

The IT barbarian - eNTP - 6w7-4-8 so/sx
Local time
Today 1:57 PM
Joined
Sep 18, 2019
Messages
513
---
Location
Your mother's basement
I can see how that might give you an idea of how to understand the E/I dichotomy. But since you've only said that when it comes to the J/P dichotomy, INTs are the same in terms of farsighted v carefree, it seems like you're NOT addressing this, which is the OP's problem:


INTJs and INTPs have several points of divergence based on the function model, 3 of them being of main concern. I did explain this to OP in another thread, pointing out clear differences between all NT types.

If she can decide between the below mentioned, while having INT selected here ( http://zhilkin.com/socio/en/ ) e_e it will point to the correct type. One is enough, but all need to fit.

4551




4552


Example of this in my case concerning process orientation. I played classic wow these past weeks and I experience needing to switch leveling zones without fully completing one as annoying and jarring. Its like some kind of sudden OCD kicks in, the need to tick off quests before moving on. If I have to delete a quest from the log to make room..it gets even worse, cus I lose track of progress.

4553
 

Rebis

Blessed are the hearts that can bend
Local time
Today 11:57 AM
Joined
Oct 6, 2019
Messages
1,669
---
Location
Ireland
So what, you got payed a fat sum to essentially change the gateway address through their new modem, different wifi protocols (WEP to WPA2/3) so network packets can be sent/recieved? Suspiciously dumb, what company is this? Given the only variable is a modem I know this should've been the only resolution.

XD its a semi-automated factory that produces paper cups lmao. A lot of companies here cut IT costs by not employing people or having ppl from other sectors be responsible for upkeep. I work at an Austrian factory for example (86 ppl), we basically build those giant illuminated signs you see on stadiums, supermarkets, malls, stores and other stuff like gas station pylons. Even here I have 2 other jobs on top of network administration & computer repair:

1. Responsible for legal waste disposal and environmental protection. I get rid of industrial waste and report statistics to the Romanian government / do all the annoying paperwork.

2. Responsible for raw material and tool acquisition for production. I basically order the stuff we make our products out of as well as manage and acquire the tools & machines we use, including IT. e_e some things are externalized so I manage transportation and contact with other companies which basically make this stuff for us.

:/ we used to be 2 ppl, but the other old guy quit. I'm thinking of quitting too. The job is boring AF, I get a raise every year, but its nothing substantial... e_e the worst part is my ESTJ boss, miss second in command nutcase drama queen, miss "Its logical no!?" Hate that bitch..

e_e what.. lol no. I wish it was that simple. Idk, their network is rather old it seems (2011). Over here most ISPs use PPOE, there is a fiberoptics connection to the modem, which then is connected to either a router or in this case another server that runs pfsense. That server died along with the modem (power surge issue? idk), they called the ISP cus no net obviously and they came & bypassed the entire thing, changed the static IPs on the printers and reconnected the workstations to the newly installed router. XD but they had no idea how the internal network layout was, neither does anyone there and the windows database server was ignored for some reason. Ofc the server had a static IP and didn't connect to the new network, the same goes for the fingerprint scanners, other wireless routers, and machines in the production facility. ^^ they have databases running on the windows server for applications they use. Only the internet was running in the main office & they could print. :)) they didn't even know the password or user to the new router. :)))))) I checked the model, got the default PW for it and magic e_e I was in... which was scary cus it meant a random guy with a laptop in the courtyard could get in... the network was not secure at all. (ISP personnel ....smh)

I just checked the IP most things were running on, reconfigured the router, undid what the ISP screwed up and got the database server running, secured the router. O.o curiously they could never get the fingerprint scanners to work be4, e_e but those were on yet another completely different IP.. I just reconfigured them to the new one and everything worked.

When I have time I'll fix the pfsense server, It looks like its just a psu failure. The new router is not good for the amount of data they have running through the network. The raid in the windows server is old af, HDDs as well ^^; I told the boss, but its not my fault they are cheap & dumb.

So it was the ISPs fault all along, not just a change of the router.
That conundrum would've annoyed me greatly but it does seem like a straightforward fix, most of your time was just diagnosing ioT issues. Hopefully the money was good.
 

scorpiomover

The little professor
Local time
Today 11:57 AM
Joined
May 3, 2011
Messages
3,383
---
Sounds more like ENTP v ENTJ.

INTJs are normally trying to push for a commitment to a course of action long before anyone is going anywhere near making a decision.

INTPs and ISTPs normally defer decisions until the facts speak for themselves. E.G. an STP mechanic I know was approached by a client who had an oil leak in her car. He couldn't find it, and said that to find it, the car would need to be clean and so she'd need to get the car steam-cleaned. She kept badgering him about fixing it. He kept saying that there was no way to tell what the problem was or what to do about it, until she had it steam-cleaned.

FYI, she went to another garage and paid hundreds of pounds. The leak was still there. Came back to him. He told her again to get it steam-cleaned. Finally, she did it. Turned out it was a broken washer. If she'd listened and just got it steam-cleaned in the first place, it would have cost £25 for the steam-cleaning and 25 pence for the washer.

This is very disturbing. INTJs are proud of how cold and unfeeling they can be.

INTPs are usually saying that other people seem to like having them around a lot more than they expect.

As to order, I'd say that NPs tend to bounce in their thinking. But it's really only SJs that like to follow a specific order. NJs love to change the order all the time, when it solves a short-term problem.

Example of this in my case concerning process orientation. I played classic wow these past weeks and I experience needing to switch leveling zones without fully completing one as annoying and jarring. Its like some kind of sudden OCD kicks in, the need to tick off quests before moving on. If I have to delete a quest from the log to make room..it gets even worse, cus I lose track of progress.
Ne loves to bounce.

Js and Ps focus on the end goals and the next move. Js focus on the next move as a means to move them forwards towards their goals. Ps tend to focus on the next move, as without the next move, the end goal can never be reached. Similar focusses, but different priorities.

Are you perceiving the differences between ENTPs and ENTJs/ESTJs as the J/P dichotomy?
 

Kormak

The IT barbarian - eNTP - 6w7-4-8 so/sx
Local time
Today 1:57 PM
Joined
Sep 18, 2019
Messages
513
---
Location
Your mother's basement
Sounds more like ENTP v ENTJ.

INTJs are normally trying to push for a commitment to a course of action long before anyone is going anywhere near making a decision.

You are talking about the Reasonable vs Decisive dichotomy here. INTPs aka LII (INTj) are reasonable, they will overthink be4 deciding, INTJs aka ILI (INTp) are decisive by contrast.
IJs are Si or Ni doms which is marked by a tendency towards physical inaction unless pushed to. This is characteristic of INTJs which require Se to drive them out if their own heads and into the real world (Se inferior being the dual seeking function). Its a tradeoff a Se dom is active, but lacks a north star (guidance), Ni doms provide that guidance, Se doms provide the push. Despite this inaction, Ni doms know what they want, they just suck at Se and can't provide it themselves. Ni doms are probably the most disconnected from the real world.

This is very disturbing. INTJs are proud of how cold and unfeeling they can be.

INTPs are usually saying that other people seem to like having them around a lot more than they expect.

This is again something different. Emotive vs Constructive. INTJs are constructive and maked by a morbid inability to show emotions. Its their major drawback (0 Fe preference). Its called being Fe PolR....the point of least resistance.

Description of Fe PolR: A type with Fe Fe PoLR does not see the point of activities revolving around excessive displays of emotion or behavior that does not reach a concrete or tangible outcome. They would rather keep conversations serious and to the point, for he/she is overwhelmed by such emotional expression, making it quite difficult to express themselves. In social interactions they will make a serious effort to reduce their level of emotive expressiveness such as being too joyful or sad, believing that showing these signs will make them vulnerable to be influenced by others. They don't hold quite a high standard for how people as a group feel about something (even if outnumbered by many when making a personal decision), and instead value situations where they can speak their own subjective opinions and feelings freely.

For INTPs Fe is a dual seeking function. Its like Se is for INTJs.. something they can't provide but need. INTPs will enjoy social harmony, being included, appreciated and listened to. they need someone who is good at creating social harmony, someone who will include them into the process. A real INTP will not be overwhelmed by Fe, for them, Fe has a soothing effect... In contrast, INTJs will be overwhelmed and they don't see the point of Fe / cannot appreciate it.


Are you perceiving the differences between ENTPs and ENTJs/ESTJs as the J/P dichotomy?

MBTI J-P dichotomy is vague and useless imo. In MBTI terms its rather simple, depends on what the judging function is. Te and Fe preference as secondary means IJ, as primary mens EJ, Fi & Ti primary means IP, secondary EP. Under socionics things are a bit more complicated.

With that said I do test as a very high P oddly. I have a sneaking suspicion that its related to orderliness and self discipline, which are very low for me despite testing high in coscientiousness on the big5.

Ne loves to bounce.

^^ I'm a completionist. I hate being disconnected from the process. A zone has a questline to follow, decoupling from the story for the sake of lvling feelsbadman. I am engaged with that zone's story, when I have to disengage and cut the story off, it sucks.

Its like when you are doing X, in the thick of it, a flow state and then you have to stop doing x and go do Y.... why the fuck?! It bothers me. How am I supposed to drum up the necessary interest to get back into flow again?

A good analogy here is getting blueballs, because I stopped before I came. Now my nuts are in pain and I don't feel like fucking.

Js and Ps focus on the end goals and the next move. Js focus on the next move as a means to move them forwards towards their goals. Ps tend to focus on the next move, as without the next move, the end goal can never be reached. Similar focusses, but different priorities.

The extraverted reasonable types (ESE, ILE, LSE, IEE) and introverted decisive types (IEI, LSI, ILI and ESI) are tactical types that focus on methods, while extraverted decisive (EIE, SLE, LIE, SEE) and introverted reasonable types (SEI, LII, SLI and EII), focus on the goal aka strategic.
 

Rebis

Blessed are the hearts that can bend
Local time
Today 11:57 AM
Joined
Oct 6, 2019
Messages
1,669
---
Location
Ireland
"INTJ or INTP how do you know"

Employing a simple syllogism

"J and P is a dichotomy"
"A coin is a dichotomy"
Therefore, J and P can be found by flipping a coin. Heads for J, Tails for P.
 

Kormak

The IT barbarian - eNTP - 6w7-4-8 so/sx
Local time
Today 1:57 PM
Joined
Sep 18, 2019
Messages
513
---
Location
Your mother's basement
XD J-P does not exist as a dichotomy.... FUUUUUUUUUUUUUU
 

Rebis

Blessed are the hearts that can bend
Local time
Today 11:57 AM
Joined
Oct 6, 2019
Messages
1,669
---
Location
Ireland
"Kormak is an ENTP"
"ENTPs employ devil's advocate"

Therefore, kormak is employing devil's advocate for the sake of argument! In which case I will rise above this petty squabble and recognise my opinion is the only valid one! :o
 

Kormak

The IT barbarian - eNTP - 6w7-4-8 so/sx
Local time
Today 1:57 PM
Joined
Sep 18, 2019
Messages
513
---
Location
Your mother's basement
What have I done! OMG ppl are no longer taking me seriously...

4590
 

Daddy

Making the Frogs Gay
Local time
Today 6:57 AM
Joined
Sep 1, 2019
Messages
462
---
INTPs and INTJs are pretty similar. They are both abstract thinkers and introverts and have problems with being down to earth, but

I think 'true' INTPs like and see the value in Fe, but easily get overwhelmed by it due to introversion. Deep down on a psychic level they want to emotionally charge situations for positive ends, maybe to get people excited or engaged about something they think is important or just to connect with people, build a rapport, and have fun. Their ego problem or spiritual growth is in learning how to balance the sometimes jarring evaluations of Ti with their desire to affect positively.

INTJs on the other hand are more desiring of Se, but also get overwhelmed by it and don't know how to interact with their environments directly in a way that's positive. Whereas the INTP has an affectual problem, the INTJ has a problem with living in the moment. Ni is like dreaming about reality, taking a step back, disengaging, and letting your mind get absorbed by the meanings and potentials and energy all around you. It takes time to process. But learning how to come back to reality and engage it directly and well is what an INTJ needs and seeks.

But maybe it could be said that the biggest difference is that INTPs don't really care about Se or coming back down to earth, whereas an INTJ doesn't really care about Fe and having affectual relations. Not to say that each couldn't do that if they wanted to or needed to, but I think it's generally avoided. INTJ is more action oriented and INTP more affectual oriented, probably, at least in terms of the function theory anyway. It's of course debatable if people really fall cleanly into these MBTI archetypes all that well anyway though.
 

dragula

Member
Local time
Today 12:57 PM
Joined
Jan 15, 2020
Messages
81
---
Rather a bit of flatulence.

Anyway, to be a bit more serious, INTP and INTJ cognitive stacks are too different.
Ti Ne Si Fe vs Ni Te Fi Se.

It's more of a flaw in MBTI as a test rather than confusion within the MBTI type self.

"J and P is a dichotomy"
"A coin is a dichotomy"
Therefore, J and P can be found by flipping a coin. Heads for J, Tails for P.

Stress situations can trigger different cognitive functions from the whole stack though (making you think you are INTP <> INTJ.)
 

Rebis

Blessed are the hearts that can bend
Local time
Today 11:57 AM
Joined
Oct 6, 2019
Messages
1,669
---
Location
Ireland
Rather a bit of flatulence.

Anyway, to be a bit more serious, INTP and INTJ cognitive stacks are too different.
Ti Ne Si Fe vs Ni Te Fi Se.

It's more of a flaw in MBTI as a test rather than confusion within the MBTI type self.

"J and P is a dichotomy"
"A coin is a dichotomy"
Therefore, J and P can be found by flipping a coin. Heads for J, Tails for P.

Stress situations can trigger different cognitive functions from the whole stack though (making you think you are INTP <> INTJ.)

Yeah, Stress can induce temporal adaptations to the cognitive stack as per the environment demands. With the removal of the stressor people regress to their natural behaviour. Having said that, stress can be long-term associated with a job-role which could result in a transformation of the person's cognitive functions indefinitely. "Going native" in other words.
 

OmoInisa

Active Member
Local time
Today 11:57 AM
Joined
Jan 3, 2014
Messages
207
---
Location
London, UK
IJs are Si or Ni doms which is marked by a tendency towards physical inaction unless pushed to.

Well. This may be true of INJs, but it's rather less true of ISJs, who are sensors after all. They may not have the wanderlust of SPs, but inaction isn't really an affliction they suffer from, at least in those domains within their experiential library.
What they do share by virtue of their Pi is a yearning for novelty, but of course novelty of different kinds, suitably provided by their respective inferior functions.

This is characteristic of INTJs which require Se to drive them out if their own heads and into the real world (Se inferior being the dual seeking function). Its a tradeoff a Se dom is active, but lacks a north star (guidance), Ni doms provide that guidance, Se doms provide the push.

True

Ni doms are probably the most disconnected from the real world.

I would say we're most disconnected from our PoLR, not our suggestive. Ni doms are more disconnected from social adaptation than they are from the Se 'real world'. It is INPs who are most up against it in understanding and surviving in the world.

For INTPs Fe is a dual seeking function. Its like Se is for INTJs.. something they can't provide but need. INTPs will enjoy social harmony, being included, appreciated and listened to. they need someone who is good at creating social harmony, someone who will include them into the process.

Yes

A real INTP will not be overwhelmed by Fe, for them, Fe has a soothing effect... In contrast, INTJs will be overwhelmed and they don't see the point of Fe / cannot appreciate it.

This is an overreach of Socionics. It simply isn't true that we don't see the point of our PoLR. An intelligent and mature INTJ will appreciate the value of Fe; she would just be averse to and relatively impotent with it.
It's equally untrue that an INTP will not be overwhelmed by Fe. It's soothing and 'dualising' in small doses; but in more than small doses, it's overwhelming. Again, the notion of the suggestive being never too much of a good thing is an absurdity necessitated by the duality totem.

MBTI J-P dichotomy is vague and useless imo.

It has its weaknesses, sure, especially in the form envisioned in Gifts Differing. But to the extent that it describes real world effects, it's actually more useful than the Socionics rational/irrational concept in understanding behaviour.
Its core weakness, and where it falls short of real life, emanates from the inadequate grasp of Se in MBTI. This is a key area that Socionics has much to teach.
It's why ESPs are conceptualised in MBTI as 'playmates', whereas Socionics correctly depicts Se as sheer volitional 'force'. Hence an SP has a lot more in common with an NJ in how he acts on the world (he's very 'J-like'), than he does with an NP.

Furthermore, since J-P makes no distinction between whether the J-P is dom or aux (i.e. all 8 type that primarily extrovert perception are lumped together), there is a problem introduced by the tendency to describe the dichotomy on the basis of Je-dom vs Pe-dom. Socionics doesn't have this problem, since rational/irrational takes only the dominant function, and given that the dominant is the most fundamental element, Socionics gives itself the opportunity to be more precise on that issue.

All that being said, the MBTI J-P is a very real and useful dichotomy (obviously, since it springs out of function dynamics. Denying its usefulness requires denying the usefulness of a function-oriented perspective on typology).
For me the key insight made possible by it is how Js and Ps process the world differently.
Js can be seen to have a hierarchical and sequential bias in their organisation of their reality (this runs right through from the 'meek and demure' ISFJs to the 'marshalling' ENTJs).
Ps can be seen to be more spacial and associative in their organisation of their reality (this applies equally to INFPs as it does to ESTPs).
It is this that creates, among other things, the 'scattered' ambience of P-ness and the 'organised' ambience of J-ness.
 

ZenRaiden

One atom of me
Local time
Today 11:57 AM
Joined
Jul 27, 2013
Messages
5,262
---
Location
Between concrete walls
My biggest weakness in life is getting the nuts and bolts of problems down. I could probably boost my productivity by 100 fold if only I ever focus on doing things more sensor like. I just have a bad habit of avoiding details.
 

BurnedOut

Your friendly neighborhood asshole
Local time
Today 5:27 PM
Joined
Apr 19, 2016
Messages
1,457
---
Location
A fucking black hole
INTPs go meta very quickly.

I have seen only one INTJ in my life and that man has an unbelievable amount of self-confidence, reassurance and poise in his actions. He has excellent analytical abilities and even excellent modes of implementing them. There is no doubt that the man is capable of bowing to himself or others' opinions if he does not feel like. He has worked for the UN and now he's routinely helps the Indian Government - Central and State as a consultant.

I think that I am quite the opposite of him due to one regard - Self-doubt and depersonalized attitude

It is not easy to figure out whether you are an INTP or an INTJ many times because of the hazy definitions of their personalities.

For some time, I got genuinely confused whether I was and INTJ or not. This is because of these things -
1) I like my plans being practical
I forgot the fact that I wanted my plans to be so logical that when I am going to implement them, they will not contradict. In other words, I erroneously defined practicality as logical soundness because I thought - "Well, how can you implement stuff which is not logically sound.". You can see how erroneous my own assumption is practically.

2) I have good Fi
Yes, I am able to identify emotions, aspirations and motivation and pretty much adhere to all the textbook definitions. However, I figured that my Fi needs to be consciously evoked in a lot of cases. It works in the background and not in the foreground. Therefore, I tend to use Fi like a tool than apply it naturally as if it is an innate personality trait. This means that my usage of Fi is not as natural as an INTJ which is very much visible after I compare myself with the supramentioned guy.

3) I have good Se
Yes, I am able to be very very aware of my surroundings when I choose to be. That does not come naturally to me. However, I seem to be not able to filter stimuli as it arrives and therefore I can feel overstimulated without remembering or paying attention to the stimuli. This one is a little complex to understand, therefore I want you to imagine yourself being in a situation where your thinking is so powerful that it drowns even your low latent inhibition. However, when it shuts down, you find yourself getting overstimulated. In other words, I am perceptible when I want to be and I am not naturally. It works when I use it.

4) I have good Ni
This is arguably one of the things that really confused me. I actually have a good Ni because I can leave much to the preconscious perception of the brain. However, I had to really train my mind by a lot of reading, music and other activities to hone my Ni. So again, it does not come naturally.

5) I have good Te
I will not boast but I think that I am a good administrator. But again. I had to train my mind, learn the discipline before getting better at it.

Now, the irony is that, many INTPs here tend to use some of their shadow functions quite well. Some of them barely sound like INTPs on the surface because they are so multifaceted in their abilities. it looks like many INTPs figure out the advantages of their shadow functions and tend to rely on it since an early age. However, again, it all boils down to pretension by overusage of those tools or maturity by discerning use.

That being said, the indicators with the most veracity that someone is an INTP are these
1) They are very penetrating in their analysis
During the implementation phase, they will take a lot of time or if it gets too much, they have a common ability to
2) Walk away when overburdened
3) Unpredictability
4) Much more meta than an INTJ
5) Depersonalized
Many INTPs treat themselves as being a welter of personalities. An INTJ won't do the same. The INTJ I know is like a bullet, a singular bullet, jacketed and propelled by a fuel as a singular entity towards the achievement of its goal. I regard INTPs as being a team - a noisy one with a lot of dissenters.
 

crippli

disturbed
Local time
Today 12:57 PM
Joined
Jan 15, 2008
Messages
1,779
---
Unpredictability...i've heard this in in my younger days. How so?
 

crippli

disturbed
Local time
Today 12:57 PM
Joined
Jan 15, 2008
Messages
1,779
---
But I don't understand the ... point .. Well. It's very accurate. and spot on. Excelent work.
 

BurnedOut

Your friendly neighborhood asshole
Local time
Today 5:27 PM
Joined
Apr 19, 2016
Messages
1,457
---
Location
A fucking black hole
Unpredictability
Not holding a certain position when you find there is ample justification in your mind for leaving it. This is basically called adapting.

By unpredictability, I do not mean suddenly changing your mind for the heck of it. Such unpredictability is displayed by each type. If it is high then it is a symptom of brain damage or severe psychological problem. However, when a person quickly changes his/her mind with some justification for it, it is also known as 'being unpredictable' because the person observing the 'unpredictable' person cannot always ascertain the motives.

That being said, INTPs tend to suddenly shift your positions, point of views, go against their own arguments, self-contradictions because they find it easy to shift their positions according the evidence that they have in hand. But understand that the same thing violates the value system of many people who are not able to readily shift their positions. Yes, INTPs can be obdurate many times but it seems that they are a higher-than-normal tendency to change their positions on things. However, you will find ENTPs, ENFPs to be the most whimsical of all the types.
 

crippli

disturbed
Local time
Today 12:57 PM
Joined
Jan 15, 2008
Messages
1,779
---
So with ample justification one can hold the position?
 

Black Rose

An unbreakable bond
Local time
Today 4:57 AM
Joined
Apr 4, 2010
Messages
11,431
---
Location
with mama
INTJ = Anticipitory Synthesis

INTP = Analytic Novelty

INTJ creates things by knowing what is needed before they create it and for every possible turnaround that may impede the process. With INTJ they want to get somewhere, in their heart they have something they value and must bring to life. So what must be thought of is what will and won't bring it about. Not like ENTJ who just create and create and create. INTJ has a singular focus, what they value above all else. Te understands causes so build anything that can function as a tool or direct any situation as a desired outcome. Ni sees what results are needed and Te with its empirical knowledge creates them.

INTP breaks ideas down into parts then generates more ideas and breaks them down into more parts. Whatever cannot be broken down survives as a sound system. INTP systems are robust because they entail many subsystems. Parts that can be thought of as irreducible chucks. It is like legos: Ne is combining them in novel ways and Ti is deconstructing them. Building up and tearing down. Many constructs are created in their minds that happen to be good for practical things. They are in their heads dissecting every possible thought they have.

INFP = Intrinsic Novelty

They think of all kinds of ideas and then evaluate them as potentially valuable or not valuable. But because they cannot create them as effectively as a T user they hold on to certain ideas more so than others. They want perfect ideas and search for them. As those ideas are important to the INFP they developed Te in such a way as to produce many smaller models of the valued idea refining it until it is perfected.
 

LOGICZOMBIE

welcome to thought club
Local time
Today 5:57 AM
Joined
Aug 6, 2021
Messages
2,811
---
INTP breaks ideas down into parts then generates more ideas and breaks them down into more parts. Whatever cannot be broken down survives as a sound system. INTP systems are robust because they entail many subsystems. Parts that can be thought of as irreducible chucks. It is like legos: Ne is combining them in novel ways and Ti is deconstructing them. Building up and tearing down. Many constructs are created in their minds that happen to be good for practical things. They are in their heads dissecting every possible thought they have.

sounds about right


i'd say INTP is much less interested in determining if something is "good or bad" and more interested in "exploring unconventional ideas"

INTJ is more focused on figuring out what is "the best solution"

 

birdsnestfern

Earthling
Local time
Today 6:57 AM
Joined
Oct 7, 2021
Messages
1,897
---
Every test I take shows extreme Perceiver, 95% P. If I ever had any J it has been abolished by choice mostly.
I 95% N 60% T 60% P 95%

I do not like the Judging function much, I like to stay open to new data every moment. Don't need closure either because I'm not attaching myself to any outcomes. I like to be fluid and changeable and flow with things. I don't want to stick with one belief because if life teaches you anything, its to be flexible. The universe changes every day. Staying open to new data is the only thing that makes sense.
 

LOGICZOMBIE

welcome to thought club
Local time
Today 5:57 AM
Joined
Aug 6, 2021
Messages
2,811
---
Every test I take shows extreme Perceiver, 95% P. If I ever had any J it has been abolished by choice mostly.
I 95% N 60% T 60% P 95%

I do not like the Judging function much, I like to stay open to new data every moment. Don't need closure either because I'm not attaching myself to any outcomes. I like to be fluid and changeable and flow with things. I don't want to stick with one belief because if life teaches you anything, its to be flexible. The universe changes every day. Staying open to new data is the only thing that makes sense.

agreed
 

ZenRaiden

One atom of me
Local time
Today 11:57 AM
Joined
Jul 27, 2013
Messages
5,262
---
Location
Between concrete walls
What I found out that most conversation, the old ones, between INTPs, seem fairly different from what you expect from normal people.
Half the shit INTPs say casually is something you would not say in real life, but INTPs seem to disagree on the most absurd points.

Puzzling out a complete framework is where INTP minds are.

The chaos in the framework can seem absent minded, but once all peaces of puzzle fit it you will see a clear picture. Whatever the picture is, INTPs accept it.

INTJs don't accept things. They define things Fi and then work to push all their mind into the perfect outcome, a type of framework that has lots of dynamic.

Its as if all INTJ data have vector.

My mind tends to get stuck and become stubborn or rigid if some minor piece of puzzle is missing. I work around it fluidly, but it gnaws at my mind like a parasite until I find the right place for that piece of puzzle.

INTPs have a clarity. INTJs have crisp clear cut defined objective.
Sometimes I rely on habits just to make life doable, so I avoid indecision.
Because in the event I have to make a decision now, my mind goes into a frenzy between all the variables and invariably I end up doing nothing, but thinking.

When I was a child I was considered slow.
It took me for ever to tie my shoes, or my parents had to wait until I finish that picture. Most kids got shit done in one second, I would be taking my time.

However once I figure out something to my satisfaction you won't find a quicker person.
I hate todays fast paced world, where its all NOW, just do it, be in the moment and just wing it, and you got to hit those numbers, just one more, etc.
All these slogans are erasing human thinking.
How is a INTP supposed use potential when 90 percent situations are antithetical to it.
When people ask me stuff, like what are you going to do with your life, Id just go bzzzz and my brain goes boom.
I know what to do, but explaining it is not linear anyway.
 

LOGICZOMBIE

welcome to thought club
Local time
Today 5:57 AM
Joined
Aug 6, 2021
Messages
2,811
---
(1) do you think a person should get their sense of self-worth from within themselves or from what other people think of them?

(2) do you prefer to be spontaneous and go out and travel and do things "IRL" or do you prefer to think about doing things and lose yourself in movies and television shows and books ?

(3) do you think people should generally trust their gut or do you think people should generally think things through ??

(4) do you think people should follow a strict core code of laws or principles no matter what, or do you think that people should follow different rules in different situations ??
 

ZenRaiden

One atom of me
Local time
Today 11:57 AM
Joined
Jul 27, 2013
Messages
5,262
---
Location
Between concrete walls
(1) do you think a person should get their sense of self-worth from within themselves or from what other people think of them?
From within.

(2) do you prefer to be spontaneous and go out and travel and do things "IRL" or do you prefer to think about doing things and lose yourself in movies and television shows and books
Both. Depends what type of activity. But the later is more common nowadays, trying to do the former.
(3) do you think people should generally trust their gut or do you think people should generally think things through ??
When its people gut, when its quantum physics think.
(4) do you think people should follow a strict core code of laws or principles no matter what, or do you think that people should follow different rules in different situations ??
EH, hard to say. I love following good rules, but rules are so stupid sometimes.
FML.
 

birdsnestfern

Earthling
Local time
Today 6:57 AM
Joined
Oct 7, 2021
Messages
1,897
---
1) 80% self 20% others
At least to get some input but mostly within

2) After Covid it’s about survival
used to be 75% doing 25% recuperating. now it’s 95% recuperating 5% doing

3) Both. Think about things separately ahead, then intuit in real life in the moment. I don’t feel it in gut though-it’s downloaded in consciousness in head as intuition. Claircognizance.

4) Both. Try to follow rules 90% but allow for 10% breakage of them depends on the situation. Mostly rules can be broken when they need to be.

*********
Self love IS success.
Both in metaphysical sense and real sense.
grow through self love.
Don't rush your development, one step at a time.
Calm down the mind. Its ok to heal now.
Slow down the pace.
 

Black Rose

An unbreakable bond
Local time
Today 4:57 AM
Joined
Apr 4, 2010
Messages
11,431
---
Location
with mama
I do not think it is about dichotomy questions.

You need to understand what NiTe is and what TiNe is.

INTJ - observe what works and know when to apply what they know works.

INTP - contemplates ideas and mentally tests them to their core foundations.

So to know if you are an INTJ or INTP just look at what you do:

Are you testing ideas until they break and don't let up on any inconsistency? (INTP)

or

Do you look for any avenue to the attainment of what needs to be and wait for the right moment to apply it? (INTJ)

If you are still confused:

INTJs are extraverted in what they are achieving but convergent in what they perceive. They see how results happen and they intuitively know when the right moment is to get results.

INTPs are extraverted in ideas, they enumerate diverse ideas and do not try to achieve anything with them other than ordering their thoughts so they know exactly what is true. Every thought is to be in perfect order but random ideas are so numerous they cannot stop ontologizing them ground up.
 
Top Bottom