Am I to understand you don't have a position about it? For a moment there it looks like you understand the Bush-ian POV quite well, but you don't exactly support it.
I do my best to understand all things, and accept all individuals points of view. Doesn't mean that that understanding precludes me from thinking them nuts, or to repeatedly rely on one quote from Saki, that I don't think they would be enormously improved by death.
This especially applies to anyone who claims to speak for God.
On the other hand, Bush's reasoning is unimpeachable
if one accepts the premises from which he starts; and a large proportion of Americans do agree with him. --- After all, he was elected by them twice...
What are Prepositional Nations?
Meh, it should be Propositional. My apologies.
Whereas most 'nations' are formed by a heterogenous mix of vaguely related tribes and persons sharing a common heritage; the
propositional theory, not solely due to liberal/neocon idealism, but partly from the equally unrealistic principles --- the law of wholly unintended consequences starts here --- laid down by the triumphant revolutionaries, together with subsequent American Exceptionalism, views becoming an American as an act of will, attainable by all, and to which all men aspire. And
must aspire. Failure to wish to become American, as George Gorer observed in his sociological study after WWII, is ascribed to perversity or weakness of will.
By this notion of nationhood as creed, if the whole of India was transplanted to the USA, edging out the present inhabitants, and they accepted American Ideals they would be instantly as fully American as Lincoln and Lee, and common heirs to those rather than remaining Indians with a hindu heritage.
People who believe that sort of thing are by necessity bound to continue this intrusion of
morals into all politics and international actions. As did Bush.
May Gog and Magog watch you, and bless you in all you do.
Claverhouse
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/16897/168973591eb22bf3853854f5e48de16cbcaaae0e" alt="Phear :phear: :phear:"