Temperaments - MBTI sorting

[darude11]

Well, it all started when I found out Keirsey [1]... His sorting is just like "SP - sanguine, NT - melancholy, etc." and I tried it on my class at high school. 99% of outcomes were just right!
Then, I have found theory about something like sorting 4 temperaments to some kind of - well, you will see in link [2]. I just realized, that extroversion and introversion are in MBTI already and stable/unstable are J/P. So outcomes were, like "melancholic - IP (which, again, is true if applied on me), choleric - EP etc." (but now I am not sure if stable/unstable isn't neurotic dichotomy from big five).

Well, I have just got mess of it, so... could you give me some information about your experiences or something about temperaments in mbti? Thanks

 

[EyeSeeCold]

Huh?

There are a few ways you can organize them, no way is static or perfect.

My favorite is:

Sanguine - EP - hot*wet ()
Melancholic - IP - cold*wet
Phlegmatic - IJ - cold*dry
Choleric - EJ - hot*dry

 

[Anthile]

http://www.cracked.com/video_18260_which-ninja-turtle-are-you-lifes-most-important-question.html

 

[darude11]

That one with turtles have got me
And that with I/E and J/P... hmm... choleric is planning his things? well, I am not so good in these things, so lets say yes

 

[boondockbabe]

ok check out theese sites they might help:
http://typelogic.com/intp.html
http://www.personalitypathways.com/article/type-dynamics.html

 

[darude11]

ok check out theese sites they might help:
http://typelogic.com/intp.html
http://www.personalitypathways.com/article/type-dynamics.html

my problem is not that I don't know how to get functions of person from the acronym... my problem is that I can't find the set of temperaments that suit the dichotomies (or attitudes for I/E) in the best way...

anyway, I have just found this one: http://www.socionics.com/articles/mytake.html it is about 4 temperaments, that are based on I/E and J/P and, well, it fits quite well for now

 

[boondockbabe]

Glad you found what you were looking for.

 

[darude11]

I have just found another theory, but you should say how much it is true

ISTJ: pure Melancholy
ISFJ: PhlegmaticMelancholy
INFJ: MelancholyPhlegmatic
INTJ: MelancholyCholeric
ISTP: MelancholySanguine
ISFP: PhlegmaticSanguine
INFP: Phlegmatic and/or Supine
INTP: PhlegmaticCholeric
ESTP: CholericSanguine
ESFP: pure Sanguine
ENFP: SanguinePhlegmatic
ENTP: SanguineCholeric
ESTJ: CholericMelancholy
ESFJ: SanguineMelancholy
ENFJ: CholericPhlegmatic
ENTJ: pure Choleric

 

[SkyWalker]

Well, it all started when I found out Keirsey [1]... His sorting is just like "SP - sanguine, NT - melancholy, etc." and I tried it on my class at high school. 99% of outcomes were just right!
Then, I have found theory about something like sorting 4 temperaments to some kind of - well, you will see in link [2]. I just realized, that extroversion and introversion are in MBTI already and stable/unstable are J/P. So outcomes were, like "melancholic - IP (which, again, is true if applied on me), choleric - EP etc." (but now I am not sure if stable/unstable isn't neurotic dichotomy from big five).

Well, I have just got mess of it, so... could you give me some information about your experiences or something about temperaments in mbti? Thanks

stable/unstable is not J/P!

stable/unstable are the opposites in the neuroticism spectrum, which is officially lacking in MBTI

i have my own theory that neuroticism is S/N related, but it is just speculation up to now.

 

[darude11]

all right, share your theory with us (if you want of course)