Seems to me the algorithm does not work on INTPs

[ZenRaiden]

What is your take?

 

[ZenRaiden]

Or does it?

 

[ummidk]

This forum's activity suggests otherwise

 

[Black Rose]

algorithm models a person's views and categorizes them based on comparing them to others. it is limited ai but it is about predicting INTPs.

 

[ZenRaiden]

algorithm models a person's views and categorizes them based on comparing them to others. it is limited ai but it is about predicting INTPs.

Not a chance in the world.

 

[Black Rose]

What is it about INTP that makes them unpredictable?

Each person has a signature unique to them. This is distanced from what others do.

 

[Daddy]

What is it about INTP that makes them unpredictable?

Each person has a signature unique to them. This is distanced from what others do.

How would you model an outlier? Are they a model of their own? In theory, the more you deviate from accepted norms of thinking and being, the harder it is to compare and contrast with other things. Wouldn't this be a problem for AI? Would it make AI biased by not seeing people for what they are, but how they compare to everyone else?

 

[Black Rose]

What is it about INTP that makes them unpredictable?

Each person has a signature unique to them. This is distanced from what others do.

How would you model an outlier? Are they a model of their own? In theory, the more you deviate from accepted norms of thinking and being, the harder it is to compare and contrast with other things. Wouldn't this be a problem for AI? Would it make AI biased by not seeing people for what they are, but how they compare to everyone else?

If all INTP are outliers then the category INTP cannot even be registered in a model so models of other types become flaky as well.

IBM had an MBTI text detector. It looked for patterns in text. With enough data, it could give a detailed analysis.

 

[scorpiomover]

Didn't Deep Thought already say the answer was 42?

 

[ZenRaiden]

What is it about INTP that makes them unpredictable?

Each person has a signature unique to them. This is distanced from what others do.

How would you model an outlier? Are they a model of their own? In theory, the more you deviate from accepted norms of thinking and being, the harder it is to compare and contrast with other things. Wouldn't this be a problem for AI? Would it make AI biased by not seeing people for what they are, but how they compare to everyone else?

If all INTP are outliers then the category INTP cannot even be registered in a model so models of other types become flaky as well.

IBM had an MBTI text detector. It looked for patterns in text. With enough data, it could give a detailed analysis.

If you look at INTP profile you will see one thing stand out.

They are outliers. So you can clearly have an outlier category.

What is more interesting about INTPs is they are defined out of all types with the most vague adjectives. Ingenious being one of them, which is clearly anything, but outlier territory. Theoretical being another vague term, that has hardly anything to do with personality unless you are INTP. Logically consistent, and critical analytical which is synonymous with IQ and analytical thinking etc.
So INTP is precisely what you are saying should not exist.

IS there something I missed about INTPs? Layed back and lazy? Perhaps.

 

[ZenRaiden]

Didn't Deep Thought already say the answer was 42?

Yes it did. It was right it is 42. Trouble is no one gave it coordinates about how to explain the answer.

It did the thinking and it gave the exact answer people wanted.
No one bothered to realise that the answer might not be understandable
No different from running a super computer and not bothering to give it interface with humans.

Too bad.

 

[scorpiomover]

Didn't Deep Thought already say the answer was 42?

Yes it did. It was right it is 42. Trouble is no one gave it coordinates about how to explain the answer.

It did the thinking and it gave the exact answer people wanted.
No one bothered to realise that the answer might not be understandable
No different from running a super computer and not bothering to give it interface with humans.

How is that different from Google's AI?

 

[ZenRaiden]

How is that different from Google's AI?

Don't know.