Pmj's TWG/Mafia

[redbaron]

Doesn't matter though it was a comedy game and still won so you played it right in your own way.

 

[Helvete]

I wanted to suggest we test the claim by having cheese vote me with no one else voting and just see what happens. I didn't think people would listen though and there was such little time I had no idea what to do

 

[redbaron]

Best thing to do is have the two players confirmed to have working votes just vote the treestump.

 

[Cheeseumpuffs]

I wanted to suggest we test the claim by having cheese vote me with no one else voting and just see what happens. I didn't think people would listen though and there was such little time I had no idea what to do

Interesting proposal. I actually might have been on board with that. Either way it would end with me getting what I want. Either cheese's vote does nothing which means I'd be certain you were scum. Or you die and flip green which proves cheese lied and also leaves him as my only scum suspect.

 

[Helvete]

Interesting proposal. I actually might have been on board with that. Either way it would end with me getting what I want. Either cheese's vote does nothing which means I'd be certain you were scum. Or you die and flip green which proves cheese lied and also leaves him as my only scum suspect.

I know but with the amount if time left I don't think everyone would be convinced and we'd have a tie. Cheese would also try to get out of that situation (could pretty much ignore me/focus on other points. I just didn't see it working.

 

[Cheeseumpuffs]

I know but with the amount if time left I don't think everyone would be convinced and we'd have a tie. Cheese would also try to get out of that situation (could pretty much ignore me/focus on other points. I just didn't see it working.

True, cheese wouldn't have been on board with that, but given slightly more time I feel like Sinny and John might have been convinced and then we could have forced cheese into it as a group (ie. everyone unvotes except for one who leaves their vote on cheese unless he votes for you and as soon as he does vote we take the vote off him and get our answer. So basically we force either his death or a no lynch (if he's telling the truth, in which case I know you're the wolf) or you die (in which case I know he's the wolf(unless pmj pulls some wankery and tells everyone that he undid the stump status because he was the only vote or some shit like that))

 

[QuickTwist]

Yeah, these kind of games are the reason we have rules >.<

 

[Minuend]

Thirdly, why is that no matter what I do, or what results I get my HATERS always have to resort to "Sinny got lucky, Sinny just OMGUSs everyone" "Sinny obviously got help" "Sinny was pivvy to information we wasn't"

I think you might take things a bit too personal. For people new to mafia, obviously it's going to seem completely weird/ baffling you zoned in on two right scum from the start. New players don't know about tells and signs and to them it's like seeing magic, while the magician knows it's just a trick

If you don't understand the reactions, it's partly because outsiders can't see the leaps in your intuition. What you tell us you see doesn't always seem more convincing than what other say they see. If things were so easy, mafia games probably wouldn't be so popular. Some of what makes mafia appealing is people can't trust their own or others judgments.

Maybe it's different for you, I'm just trying to explain where others might come from. It's not because people don't think you're able, it's because they find it weird for even able people to pull that off. To me how you write also comes off as more "chaotic" which makes it more difficult to follow your train of thought. So to me what you wrote initially didn't come off as common sense or obvious.

Which is probably because of the way we think is just in a bit of contrast. And I think that's a good thing, because if everyone was an INTP in every mafia game, I think it would be a bit boring. Better to have different people with different ways of thinking.

It might annoy you that others don't get you and your logic straight away, but I don't think much can be done of that, except give it time. And with it, some will get you and some just never will. I think most people experience other people not getting them, some just experience it more than others

 

[cheese]

Helv/Puffs:
Ah, didn't realise there were so many other plans underway. Always interesting to see what people have going on under the surface. Your plans are good and might've worked btw, if you tried to force them through. I was planning to either make it through without voting, or die quietly, since I was already so screwed. But I LAID IT ALL ON THE LINE. MY BALLS, I JUST SWUNG 'EM OUT AND SLAPPED 'EM RIGHT DOWN ON THAT THERE LINE AND I SAID TO Y'ALL, I SAID, "MY PENIS WAS AMPUTATED AT BIRTH AND ALL I WAS LEFT WITH WAS THIS STUMP."

 

[Jennywocky]

...The Hedwig Strategy produces another winner.

 

[EyeSeeCold]

Thirdly, why is that no matter what I do, or what results I get my HATERS always have to resort to "Sinny got lucky, Sinny just OMGUSs everyone" "Sinny obviously got help" "Sinny was pivvy to information we wasn't"

I think you might take things a bit too personal. For people new to mafia, obviously it's going to seem completely weird/ baffling you zoned in on two right scum from the start. New players don't know about tells and signs and to them it's like seeing magic, while the magician knows it's just a trick

If you don't understand the reactions, it's partly because outsiders can't see the leaps in your intuition. What you tell us you see doesn't always seem more convincing than what other say they see. If things were so easy, mafia games probably wouldn't be so popular. Some of what makes mafia appealing is people can't trust their own or others judgments.

No one ever trusts Ni until it's too late.

 

[cheese]

What's the Hedwig Strategy, Jenny?

 

[Artsu Tharaz]

No one ever trusts Ni until it's too late.

So Sinny is ENTJ?

 

[PmjPmj]

/Vote redbaron

 

[Artsu Tharaz]

/vote Eminem

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K1ER5mJHkJ8

 

[Jennywocky]

Helv/Puffs:
Ah, didn't realise there were so many other plans underway. Always interesting to see what people have going on under the surface. Your plans are good and might've worked btw, if you tried to force them through. I was planning to either make it through without voting, or die quietly, since I was already so screwed. But I LAID IT ALL ON THE LINE. MY BALLS, I JUST SWUNG 'EM OUT AND SLAPPED 'EM RIGHT DOWN ON THAT THERE LINE AND I SAID TO Y'ALL, I SAID, "MY PENIS WAS AMPUTATED AT BIRTH AND ALL I WAS LEFT WITH WAS THIS STUMP."

...The Hedwig Strategy produces another winner.

What's the Hedwig Strategy, Jenny?

 

[EyeSeeCold]

So Sinny is ENTJ?

Why do you say ENTJ?

 

[Artsu Tharaz]

Why do you say ENTJ?

You seem to be suggesting that she is Ni, correct?

Which Ni type did you have in mind?

 

[EyeSeeCold]

Yes, Ni but ENTJ have something different about them regarding Ni that I won't go into here, it's not the right place/time.

 

[PmjPmj]

Actually mate, it is. The OP (me) is married to an ENTJ - so by all means, go forth

 

[EyeSeeCold]

Actually mate, it is. The OP (me) is married to an ENTJ - so by all means, go forth

What does she usually do when she finds herself ahead of the times or holding an unpopular opinion?

 

[Sinny91]

What does she usually do when she finds herself ahead of the times or holding an unpopular opinion?

I know what I do.

Dismiss everybody else as idiots, haha.

 

[PmjPmj]

What does she usually do when she finds herself ahead of the times or holding an unpopular opinion?

Bring everyone around to her way of thinking.

She's the boss anyhoo, so it's a case of 'get on board or fuck off'

 

[Cheeseumpuffs]

God dammit I still need to watch this.

 

[Jennywocky]

God dammit I still need to watch this.

I actually saw a local production live once... kinda interesting.

 

[QuickTwist]

God dammit I still need to watch this.

This made me laugh. Don't ever change Cheeseumpuffs.

 

[Cheeseumpuffs]

This made me laugh. Don't ever change Cheeseumpuffs.

Okay