Black Rose
An unbreakable bond
What is Music as it relates to functions?
(Fi Fe)
(Ti Te)
(Si Se)
(Ni Ne)
(Fi Fe)
(Ti Te)
(Si Se)
(Ni Ne)
-
OK, it's on.
Music, functions and emotion
- Thread starter Black Rose
- Start date
Ex-User (5841)
Banned
- Local time
- Today 9:56 PM
- Joined
- Jan 7, 2012
- Messages
- 5,022
I have trouble associating music with any of the introverted or intuitive functions.
For me it's all about Fe, especially the combination of the music itself and lyrics.
For me it's all about Fe, especially the combination of the music itself and lyrics.
nanook
a scream in a vortex
based on physiognomy i am convinced that many estj are
a) good composers of classic or film music
b) not so good techno djs. (i think the male guy of die antwoord is estj - the female one seems SiTe ISTp)
i think these are the most auditory types (which also has to do with T dominance), and classic music is almost about hallucinating. but subjectivity (Si) is about hallucinating something that has style.
so T dominance and Si is perfect for very technical music.
i can see many ESFJ females doing singing and or one perhaps classical instrument. there is still this tecnical perfectionistic air about it.
and esfj are highly poetic.
i think she is esfj - not an example of poetic, but of language gift and musicality
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=khCokQt--l4&feature=relmfu
and a youtube person who plays violin ... can't find her channel
i believe that pogo on youtube may be Si dominant.
he is half a musician and half a visual artist.
he may not be as auditory as estj.
he is probably a visual learning type.
i would rather expect something weird (Si) but highly creative (Ne) from Si doms, like a sort of punk, mix in some horror, fun, comedy. anything that's appealing to subjectivity. mixing up genres with a lot of style. subjective irrational synthesizing!!!
a) good composers of classic or film music
b) not so good techno djs. (i think the male guy of die antwoord is estj - the female one seems SiTe ISTp)
i think these are the most auditory types (which also has to do with T dominance), and classic music is almost about hallucinating. but subjectivity (Si) is about hallucinating something that has style.
so T dominance and Si is perfect for very technical music.
i can see many ESFJ females doing singing and or one perhaps classical instrument. there is still this tecnical perfectionistic air about it.
and esfj are highly poetic.
i think she is esfj - not an example of poetic, but of language gift and musicality
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=khCokQt--l4&feature=relmfu
and a youtube person who plays violin ... can't find her channel
i believe that pogo on youtube may be Si dominant.
he is half a musician and half a visual artist.
he may not be as auditory as estj.
he is probably a visual learning type.
i would rather expect something weird (Si) but highly creative (Ne) from Si doms, like a sort of punk, mix in some horror, fun, comedy. anything that's appealing to subjectivity. mixing up genres with a lot of style. subjective irrational synthesizing!!!
Proletar
Deus Sex Machina
I'm a musician myself (according to some sources, a guitar-sorcerer).
Good music from me comes from:
A: Understanding the formula (Ti)
B: Listening for ques from band-mates and so on (Ne)
C: Learning to play over-night (Si)
D: Expressing what I feel and recieving the general mood of the performance (Fe)
I generally like to play live, and even though I firmly enjoy mixing and other studio-work in itself, I tend to feel that the music suffers if it isn't performed live. That's just my forum, I suppose.
Good music from me comes from:
A: Understanding the formula (Ti)
B: Listening for ques from band-mates and so on (Ne)
C: Learning to play over-night (Si)
D: Expressing what I feel and recieving the general mood of the performance (Fe)
I generally like to play live, and even though I firmly enjoy mixing and other studio-work in itself, I tend to feel that the music suffers if it isn't performed live. That's just my forum, I suppose.
I've never related to how people associate music with emotions. My like for music is just that human preference for a particular range of sets of sounds. You can apply emotion on anything. Anything can have relation to emotion. Maybe it's the pure synthesis of preference and emotion that creates the confusion. That synthesis sort of sounds like passion.