So I watched Arrival last night. I thought it was an excellent film.
First of all, it sucked me in by imagining how I'd go about communicating with them. And it got me thinking about the different language structures around the world. I'd agree with idea of going for text rather than sound since their vocal patterns were obviously completely incompatible with ours - plus there's no guarantee our ears could even hear the pitches of the sounds they made.
And I liked the concept that their intentions seemed alien because they were not like us at all - what common ground could we even find. I'm not sure I could buy the twist as being a result of their language - order of words isn't always important (take Latin, for example), and I'd have thought that it would be the result of the way they perceive reality rather than the other way around. Nonetheless, the twist was excellent and unexpected until it dawned on me after she went in the last time. And from a non scientific point of view, the point of the story was clear, well played and nicely poignant. (I was watching it in bed, and my littlest had decided she was scared of a nightmare of a giant hamster so had crawled in, and I couldn't help cuddling her after watching it.
I still law awake for a while imagining what you'd do if you knew that. I couldn't imagine how it would feel and it succeeded in evoking a great sense of emotion and contemplation (which is rare for a film to do).
It's a movie about alien contact on the surface, but underneath it's really about grief and loss and what it means to be human, yet also transposed in what it could mean if we were NOT human on some levels and had other ways to cognitively understand the world. it's so big-picture, yet so personal, all at once. I was already moved after just the first five minutes, and when it goes into the aliens landing sequence where she walks into her class... creepy vibes of 9/11. That was so WTF.
and yeah, the linguistics aspects were interesting, with everything you noted. We have some experience like this even with human language -- like, when I listen to Asian languages, there are things happening in there that means something to the Asian listener that are going right over my head because I just have not been trained in the nuance of the sounds that are being used. Now imagine if your physiology isn't even capable of perceiving some of those sounds, like a dog hearing things beyond the range of audible human perception.
Anyway, glad you enjoyed it. It still chokes me up some just recalling it. Intellectually Villeneuve's movies kind of all hit me on that level, although one is the one that most emotionally grabbed me. But they're all kind of unsettling.
Enemy - a guy thinks he sees another guy who looks like him. Is he going mad? What does this mean?
Prisoners - a parent's grief leads to taking the law into one's own hands -- it's willing to explore the ambiguity between justice and revenge when the law is incapable, yet is it? It's really willing to go into unsettling territory.
Sicario - the surface of the drug trade might seem black/white, but not so much when you actually are in the rubber-meets-road area. Again, morality breaks down, conflicting against itself.
I really want to see what he does with Blade Runner 2049.
Just watched Guardians of the Galaxy 2. Love the Stan Lee cameo with the Watchers.
Boo, spoiler fiend...!
I'm going tomorrow. Had tickets for right now, but had a Central Air problem that tech could only schedule for right now. I think I'll like it based on what I've read but sometimes these kinds of movies can go either way.
No Country for Old Men.. I've seen it many times, but it's such a great film, with one of the best movie villains.
A great movie I need to rewatch soon, it's been a few years. I'm sure I missed stuff on first pass, and it was constantly breaking my expectations as an American viewer, which was good. Might be the best translation of one of McCarthy's literary works to screen? "The Road" nailed the book's tone very well but was a bit uneven in delivery, it felt like a series of cobbled together vignettes.