ruminator
INTP 4w5
- Local time
- Today 8:30 AM
- Joined
- Aug 29, 2014
- Messages
- 204
Many people say that if one is feeling sad or any such negative emotion, you should accept the emotion, allow yourself to feel it, and do something that makes you happy as a way of self-care. I know people who do this. If they are feeling depressed, they don't fight it, they just let it be, and watch a funny movie, go for a walk, take a hot bath, spend time with loved ones, paint, listen to music, etc. They take their mind off of the thing that is upsetting them, and focus on something that makes them feel good.
This TED talk is sort of about it:
She talks about how you should not fight or resist the negative emotions, and should accept them
But I see a huge problem with all this...
A lot of times negative emotions are caused by a distorted belief. "I am a failure"; "I will never get another chance"; "I needed that person whom I lost"; "It was all my fault." As long as that distorted belief is still there, you will continue to feel the way you're feeling, no matter how many happy activities you do.... In fact, it seems unhealthy to do the acceptance/self-care route because you would be accepting the emotion and therefore the underlying belief rather than fighting it. Why would you validate a distorted belief? These beliefs are not true, so it seems like it would be better to fight it and convince yourself it is not true.
What I usually do is - sit and try to figure out what I'm feeling and why I'm feeling it, to get at the underlying belief. Once I find the underlying belief, I analyze it to convince myself it's not true so I can get rid of it and make myself feel better. I would try to come up with reasons for why it's not all my fault, reasons for why I'm better off without that person, reasons for why I have nothing to feel bad about.
My method seems to be supported too because I do hear about the importance of cognitive behavioral therapy, introspection, understanding your emotions, etc. But this all seems to contradict with the self-care, accept it and do happy things advice... so I am not sure if I am understanding this properly
Honestly, I hate doing my method because it is time consuming and takes a lot of energy, thinking, and analysis. I would much much much rather take the self-care fun route. I'm just worried about whether it's a good idea to accept something that is based off an untrue belief, rather than working on getting rid of the belief.
So what do you think about the acceptance/self-care method vs. the challenging beliefs/analysis method? Do they contradict or are you supposed to use both at different times? What is your method?
This TED talk is sort of about it:
She talks about how you should not fight or resist the negative emotions, and should accept them
But I see a huge problem with all this...
A lot of times negative emotions are caused by a distorted belief. "I am a failure"; "I will never get another chance"; "I needed that person whom I lost"; "It was all my fault." As long as that distorted belief is still there, you will continue to feel the way you're feeling, no matter how many happy activities you do.... In fact, it seems unhealthy to do the acceptance/self-care route because you would be accepting the emotion and therefore the underlying belief rather than fighting it. Why would you validate a distorted belief? These beliefs are not true, so it seems like it would be better to fight it and convince yourself it is not true.
What I usually do is - sit and try to figure out what I'm feeling and why I'm feeling it, to get at the underlying belief. Once I find the underlying belief, I analyze it to convince myself it's not true so I can get rid of it and make myself feel better. I would try to come up with reasons for why it's not all my fault, reasons for why I'm better off without that person, reasons for why I have nothing to feel bad about.
My method seems to be supported too because I do hear about the importance of cognitive behavioral therapy, introspection, understanding your emotions, etc. But this all seems to contradict with the self-care, accept it and do happy things advice... so I am not sure if I am understanding this properly
Honestly, I hate doing my method because it is time consuming and takes a lot of energy, thinking, and analysis. I would much much much rather take the self-care fun route. I'm just worried about whether it's a good idea to accept something that is based off an untrue belief, rather than working on getting rid of the belief.
So what do you think about the acceptance/self-care method vs. the challenging beliefs/analysis method? Do they contradict or are you supposed to use both at different times? What is your method?