• OK, it's on.
  • Please note that many, many Email Addresses used for spam, are not accepted at registration. Select a respectable Free email.
  • Done now. Domine miserere nobis.

Has average attention span of people reduced?

CuriousMonk

Member
Local time
Today 9:04 PM
Joined
Aug 30, 2021
Messages
54
---
I think attention span of people has reduced on an average due to internet and social media revolution. Maybe its a new mass dysfunction being brought about by the internet & allied technologies like smartphones.

Increase in content on the internet is exponentially increasing in comparison to the number of consumers of that content.

What's your perception on it and what's the solution?
 

Black Rose

An unbreakable bond
Local time
Today 8:34 AM
Joined
Apr 4, 2010
Messages
11,431
---
Location
with mama
I haven't read a whole book in 7 years.
 

scorpiomover

The little professor
Local time
Today 3:34 PM
Joined
May 3, 2011
Messages
3,383
---

Ex-User (9086)

Prolific Member
Local time
Today 3:34 PM
Joined
Nov 21, 2013
Messages
4,758
---
It's easy to lose it but it's very hard to earn back. I used to have an amazing ability to focus, could work for 10 or 12 hours on a single thing that I was studying, reading or practicing.

Then I became addicted to the internet and I wasn't able to focus for more than 5 minutes. I was browsing social media, forums, entertainment and infotainment websites on binge strikes and I didn't remember much of what I did in my free time.

If you can't focus then you have to realize that there's some kind of problem, health issue, vitamin deficiency, lack of exercise or possibly an addiction. I've dealt with mine with 3 things:
1. by pulling out of almost all forms of social media and installing software that blocks unwanted distracting websites and games.
2. planning my day with windows of productivity and rest and daily goals
3. meditation helps me calm and direct my focus whenever I start thinking about 10 things at once

Currently I can focus for about 2 hours before I need to reset my attention, I track all interruptions and their causes so that I can improve it.

If you can't be productive for at least 4 hours each day or if you can't stick to any plan that you make then I'd say that there's a potential issue that you need to work on.
 

CuriousMonk

Member
Local time
Today 9:04 PM
Joined
Aug 30, 2021
Messages
54
---
@Glaerhaidh I think there are two things at work in this dynamics - attention, and will.

I'm not sure how much has the faculty of 'attention' been impacted by the social media revolution in comparison to the impact on the 'will' of humans. People still seem to be focused on things at stretch for hours (eg movies, smartphones) but not on the things that they want to focus on (eg work, studies). It's almost like, they're being 'made' to focus on the things which the companies want them to focus on (through subtle mind control and marketing).

At almost all times in human history, the free will of humans has been influenced and controlled by the culture, however, marketing, social media, and other clandestine techniques have further taken hold of our free will and hence attention. On the positive side, most humans have freed themselves from the clutches of the traditional modes of control such as - various superstitions and irrational rituals.

There has only (effectively) been a decade since the adevnt of social media revolution. I'm not sure, what will happen to our 'attention and free will' in the next few decades.
 

ANAXEL

I always get invited to parties
Local time
Today 9:34 AM
Joined
May 31, 2019
Messages
17
---
I haven't read a whole book in 7 years.
There's something I heard Maryanne Wolf on one of my favorite podcasts (Brain Science with Ginger Campbell Ep. 145) which impacted me and got me to start reading as often as I could:
"Spend, at least, 10-15 minutes reading print [daily]. [Whatever] will make you think. Think at the beginning of the day and think at the end of the day. (...) Because we have all begun to move so fast that we are retreating from the slower processes that lead us to be more thoughtful human beings".

She connects the action of reading to other brain functions that are correlated to empathy and deep thought and I think her points make a lot of sense logically and also based on my own experience with people around me and myself.

I think that, similar to exercise, learning to subject oneself to something linear that gets uncomfortable real quick and require endurance is what can lead to our concentration (and by extension patience and introspection) muscles to be strengthened.

I'm not sure how much has the faculty of 'attention' been impacted by the social media revolution in comparison to the impact on the 'will' of humans. People still seem to be focused on things at stretch for hours (eg movies, smartphones) but not on the things that they want to focus on (eg work, studies). It's almost like, they're being 'made' to focus on the things which the companies want them to focus on (through subtle mind control and marketing).

At almost all times in human history, the free will of humans has been influenced and controlled by the culture, however, marketing, social media, and other clandestine techniques have further taken hold of our free will and hence attention. On the positive side, most humans have freed themselves from the clutches of the traditional modes of control such as - various superstitions and irrational rituals.
I would say that nature follows the path of least resistance (I think free will is kind of an illusion we believe in too much but that's for a whole other conversation).

What I've experienced actually seems to differ from what you said. Less and less people are subjecting themselves to the 2-hr film experience, preferring to jump from film to film on Netflix or other streaming services. People can't be at the theater without switching to their phones on the lowest brightness settings for a couple of seconds to check social media. Most people I know listen to about 30 seconds of songs they like before switching to the next song. Tons of people are still superstitious. I live in a developed metropolis and there are still as many psychic shops as there are adult video stores. Some of the more viral videos on Youtube have thumbnails with red arrows pointing at blurry figures. And this may be reckless to say, but the infamous cancel culture and the general attitude towards political correctness is just the modern version of witch hunting and scarlet lettering, a more subtle version of superstition.

We instinctively view it as us being affected by a greater force. But I think the act of being present and mindful has never been a natural human ability. We gravitate towards what's easier, faster, and most stimulating.
Ages ago, the complaint from the most thoughtful likely was "If it weren't for those stupid pubs, men would be more caring. They'd spend time with their families instead of starting fights and getting drunk". "Everyone now can't go to the beach without having to take a book with them. It's like no one can sit still sober and just think or pray. Always have to be hooked to the latest journal. So sad"

Don't get me wrong though. Not trying to contradict what you said. The increase in technology and social media's presence have definitely worsened us. We're not monitoring our impulses, just trying to band-aid their symptoms with more conveniences. But I think this is an inevitable phase humans have to go through. I just hope the next phase doesn't mean extinction.

TL;DR
Nature takes the path of least resistance and technology creates that path, for better or worse.
 

CuriousMonk

Member
Local time
Today 9:04 PM
Joined
Aug 30, 2021
Messages
54
---
I haven't read a whole book in 7 years.
There's something I heard Maryanne Wolf on one of my favorite podcasts (Brain Science with Ginger Campbell Ep. 145) which impacted me and got me to start reading as often as I could:
"Spend, at least, 10-15 minutes reading print [daily]. [Whatever] will make you think. Think at the beginning of the day and think at the end of the day. (...) Because we have all begun to move so fast that we are retreating from the slower processes that lead us to be more thoughtful human beings".

She connects the action of reading to other brain functions that are correlated to empathy and deep thought and I think her points make a lot of sense logically and also based on my own experience with people around me and myself.

I think that, similar to exercise, learning to subject oneself to something linear that gets uncomfortable real quick and require endurance is what can lead to our concentration (and by extension patience and introspection) muscles to be strengthened.

I'm not sure how much has the faculty of 'attention' been impacted by the social media revolution in comparison to the impact on the 'will' of humans. People still seem to be focused on things at stretch for hours (eg movies, smartphones) but not on the things that they want to focus on (eg work, studies). It's almost like, they're being 'made' to focus on the things which the companies want them to focus on (through subtle mind control and marketing).

At almost all times in human history, the free will of humans has been influenced and controlled by the culture, however, marketing, social media, and other clandestine techniques have further taken hold of our free will and hence attention. On the positive side, most humans have freed themselves from the clutches of the traditional modes of control such as - various superstitions and irrational rituals.
I would say that nature follows the path of least resistance (I think free will is kind of an illusion we believe in too much but that's for a whole other conversation).

What I've experienced actually seems to differ from what you said. Less and less people are subjecting themselves to the 2-hr film experience, preferring to jump from film to film on Netflix or other streaming services. People can't be at the theater without switching to their phones on the lowest brightness settings for a couple of seconds to check social media. Most people I know listen to about 30 seconds of songs they like before switching to the next song. Tons of people are still superstitious. I live in a developed metropolis and there are still as many psychic shops as there are adult video stores. Some of the more viral videos on Youtube have thumbnails with red arrows pointing at blurry figures. And this may be reckless to say, but the infamous cancel culture and the general attitude towards political correctness is just the modern version of witch hunting and scarlet lettering, a more subtle version of superstition.

We instinctively view it as us being affected by a greater force. But I think the act of being present and mindful has never been a natural human ability. We gravitate towards what's easier, faster, and most stimulating.
Ages ago, the complaint from the most thoughtful likely was "If it weren't for those stupid pubs, men would be more caring. They'd spend time with their families instead of starting fights and getting drunk". "Everyone now can't go to the beach without having to take a book with them. It's like no one can sit still sober and just think or pray. Always have to be hooked to the latest journal. So sad"

Don't get me wrong though. Not trying to contradict what you said. The increase in technology and social media's presence have definitely worsened us. We're not monitoring our impulses, just trying to band-aid their symptoms with more conveniences. But I think this is an inevitable phase humans have to go through. I just hope the next phase doesn't mean extinction.

TL;DR
Nature takes the path of least resistance and technology creates that path, for better or worse.
Sorry, couldn't get back to you earlier. You are probably correct.

I've realised the irrelevance of this thread. Seeking opinion on these kinds of matter doesn't make sense, since it can be measured by scientific investigation.

Actually, there have been a few researches - for example, that in technical University of Denmark in 2013.

If you want to titillate your imagination, I request you to check out my thread - Liberation from Suffering; because that is the ultimate and one of the most ancient questions of the humanity. Goodluck.
 

BurnedOut

Your friendly neighborhood asshole
Local time
Today 9:04 PM
Joined
Apr 19, 2016
Messages
1,457
---
Location
A fucking black hole
Then I became addicted to the internet and I wasn't able to focus for more than 5 minutes. I was browsing social media, forums, entertainment and infotainment websites on binge strikes and I didn't remember much of what I did in my free time.
Glaerhaidh pretty much explains the problem of the 21st century. This is empirically proven. Now addiction to media is closer and closer to getting termed as a personality disorder.

When I was 15, I decided to do away with social media except WhatsApp and Telegram because my education institutions required them to be present on my phone. Facebook, Instagram, Snapchat, etc turned out to be a big menace for me when I was a teenybopper. It's been almost a decade now and I still don't regret making the call.

Research shows that people read less and less as they keep growing. Thanks to my intervention due to serendipity, I ended up reading more and more and now I am more proficient than ever.

Everybody I know except my mother and my maternal uncles are free from the clutches. We are extremely productive when we want to be. It is the price we automatically pay for not being active electronically socially. Audiovisual entertainment is much worse than aural entertainment which is worse than reading. Reading it seems was the only true modern progress that augmented the intelligence of mankind. The emergence of TV and radio have made us dumber and nothing else. And now the internet? You are more commodified than ever.

I cherish physical company with my friends and family. When I chat with them, I truly enjoy it and when I call them, I make the call count. I don't have any online friends or as such due to being a boomer regarding these things but I am happy I just lead a single life. I don't have to battle for my commodified self online. I am more in my body, I am in touch with my soul. And I can guarantee you that if you are a habitual social media user, you cannot get rid of it simply just like that. It was a very painful and hermetic process but my blooming into adulthood only proves the importance of one mind, one body and one soul.

Well, this just sounds like evangelical propaganda. But research has not proven my deductions entirely wrong either. Other than that, it is just my personality. I am not a stickler for people. So I don't know about you. But I can tell you one thing, internet has cheapened everybody in the eyes of everybody.
 

BurnedOut

Your friendly neighborhood asshole
Local time
Today 9:04 PM
Joined
Apr 19, 2016
Messages
1,457
---
Location
A fucking black hole
You may call me a sucker for spouting a line such as this - 'one mind, one body and one soul' but is it really that difficult to understand what I meant? Internet's influence alienates the personality more and more. The hunger for relating to somebody else online makes you lose your own critical thinking.

When you look in the mirror, do you see your own reflection or that of somebody who's constantly yearning for something better? Something relatable?
 

Daddy

Making the Frogs Gay
Local time
Today 10:34 AM
Joined
Sep 1, 2019
Messages
462
---
Personally, I haven't read a book in a long time, but I do listen to audiobooks because I can do something, while I listen. I can't sit and devote time to read a long book. But I don't blame social media or technology. I blame a fast-paced world. There's always something for me that I need to do - something for the house, to make money, something healthy, eating well, taking care of myself, projects, time to think and reflect, time to relax, and get sleep. How do people not have a short-attention span?
 

Puffy

"Wtf even was that"
Local time
Today 3:34 PM
Joined
Nov 7, 2009
Messages
3,859
---
Location
Path with heart
To me it's no accident that my attention span correlates to my media consumption as other's here have highlighted.

I was pretty heavily addicted to video-games until I was 19 (I mean like 8-10 hours per day.) Around the time I started university I tried doing homework assignments and realised my attention span was so shot I couldn't focus on a book beyond a couple of pages. So realising my addiction was going to be a determining factor on my performance as a student I went cold turkey. I filled the new vaccum of time with studying and gradually my focus came back and I was able to perform to a much higher standard than I'd been able to before.

Similarly I'd say my main vice since lockdown has been an emerging internet addiction. I haven't minded having some down time to not focus on any goals for a while as to be honest I think I needed that for a while. But I think I'm getting to a place of coming out of hibernation and will likely purge the addiction as I've done before. Glaerhaidh's post helped frame this so appreciate reading, I'll try something similar.
 

mikrokosmos

Redshirt
Local time
Today 3:34 PM
Joined
Jul 18, 2021
Messages
20
---
Location
United States
I haven't used sites like Facebook in a long time (first for security concerns and later because I just got disinterested), so that doesn't trouble me. What I personally find most concerning is passive consumption in enormous quantities without any interaction -- refusing to engage with the content I consume.

What's the point of gorging myself on all the information the internet has to offer if I don't do something with that knowledge? Why don't I try formulating my own opinions and sharing them with somebody instead of just reading and reading, watching and watching? I do not put forward the effort to contribute to a conversation, and that scares me.
 
Top Bottom