Yes, that was a very good post. I will now proceed to dissect it...
ROFL!
Darn, but we lose a lot of good cats that way.
I'm just going to say up front that I don't expect you personally to possibly change if you ever became a parent. I'm just saying I happen to be a person who did, and I'm aware of the possibility of things in this life that one can study and rationalize but maybe not really "grasp" in their totality until they are experienced. Not everything can be taught by a book.
But again, just because I have had this experience doesn't necessarily mean you would have the same one.
Well, I see children all the time and I was one not too long ago so it's not like I've never experienced what a child is like. I've also had to teach little kids karate before so I sort of get what everything else might be like.
I think that can be helpful. We've all been kids, but it's very different than being a parent of kids. the concerns and needs are very very different. And I think teaching kids is a better example, where you've been interacting with them; but I still equate that with being at best an aunt or uncle. It's one thing to oversee kids in one role for a few hours at a time, another thing to care for them 24/7 where they are entirely dependent on you and you can't fuck it up or they're impacted permanently by it because you are their provider, caretaker, affirmer, protector, role model, you name it. Ever tried to hide in the bathroom just for a moment's respite and had kids trying to shove things under the door or talking to you the entire time, and you just! can't! get! away! and you're not legally supposed to get in your car and just drive to Florida? Well...!
Anyway, that's a very different situation -- kind of like doing the National Guard thing every few weeks versus being in Restrepo and having your friends gunned down next to you in a trench and wondering if you'll live to see the next sunrise.
I'm downloading the movie atm and will tell you what I think of it.
lol! Well, I didn't expect that. If you can get the Director's Cut, go for that, it's a little better. It's not a perfect movie, but I'm just referring to the end scene in the hearing.
That's exactly what I think it's all about, feelings and emotional attachments. Personally I don't want to be like that, it's like a weakness. I don't want to be attached to someone so much that I would give my life for them. Even though my life is more than likely going to end eventually, I'd still rather savor every moment of it than just give it away. Besides, If I'm dead, how am I going to appreciate my child's life? If I live and they die I'll eventually get over it and continue with my life. I'm not the type to get emotionally scarred. A couple of my grandparents died a few years ago and I don't even care. I've got a large family so I've got a few grandparents left which I'm more emotionally attached to, but still, I won't be upset for long when they die. Am I cruel? Perhaps, perhaps I am.
I appreciate your honesty, and I'm glad we can discuss it so openly. I just see it as a choice that I don't expect everyone to make. I did make the choice to have children, knowing it would probably change me, and it did; and I don't regret it, but sometimes it's very odd looking back at myself at 20 and wondering if I would ever recognize that person. It was a very big decision for me, looking back. And I've been hurt, and not everything has worked out the way I'd have liked it to, and there's a few things in my life right now that really stink because I made that choice... but at the same time, I just love my kids and glad they're in the world and I like who I am now.
We just choose what we want in life, and then hopefully we made a choice that we can value later and not regret.
Why don't you just not MAKE them important by not having them? jk
Totally rational. Valid decision. If it's what you want, then that makes sense to me.
Yes, I get what you are saying. Although that chocolate example isn't good in this case because like I said I know what a child is. I've seen children, hugged children, taught children, punched children, kicked children, thrown them across the room, and listened to them ramble on about legos and their new 3DS game. I think that's close enough to parenthood for me to get it. Lol.
Well, see above -- I think it's different when they are entirely dependent on you and you don't get an escape. But come on, you've never seen, hugged, taught, punched, kicked, thrown, or listened to chocolate?
I watched the movie and it was actually pretty good. At the very end there was proof that she wasn't hallucinating though. Her camera recorded eighteen hours of static even though only a minute passed on Earth. It wasn't a mystical experience or anything, they just need to put more people into that machine to demonstrate that it is a vehicle to travel through space.
Yeah. I actually felt like it was a bit of a copout -- I like movies that are more ambiguous. But they did have proof that her experience was real.
I thought Jodie Foster did a great job with the role, and a nice example of a Rationalist female. I really related to her in spots, especially when she was in the machine and trying to observe and test and frame her experience and understand what was happening. That's very much what I would have done too.