Chart of Birthdays and MBTI - Big FIVE

[X-Logik]

1

 

[TheManBeyond]

luls

 

[Perfectly Normal Beast]

is this for the nothern hemisphere?

 

[X-Logik]

For northern hemisphere. yes

 

[The Gopher]

You should do one for the southern hemisphere.

 

[Jennywocky]

What about the western hemisphere?

I need to know what my type is.

 

[The Gopher]

East planet 4 life baby.

 

[somebodiesfool]

this is ridonkulous

 

[Brontosaurie]

ok so i'm an INTJ good to know

haha carry cola is an ENTJ, like that wasn't obvious...

 

[TheManBeyond]

Im an esfp like it wasn't prett...
Godfuck

Nawh my sister I supposedly am isfp and that's the most unlikely shit ever
My braw is an intp. Not. Perhaps an intj or istp or isfp but not a intp.

 

[Jennywocky]

cherry is such a boss... and born that way, apparently.

 

[The Gopher]

cherry is such a boss... and born that way, apparently.

Great now I have to break up my Hannibal watching with lady gaga...

I won't say what I am as I'm not convinced this isn't a scam to find out people's birth month.

 

[Inquisitor]

It says I'm an ENFP. That is incorrect. I'm INTP. I think you should look for another theory.

 

[Jennywocky]

You could just change your birthday.
(I mean, it's not his fault you were born on the wrong day.)

 

[Seteleechete]

I got INTP ^.^ must be accurate

 

[Sinny91]

I'm an ESTJ apparently.

 

[Ex-User (11125)]

You say summer I say butt sweat. You say summer I say plethora of mosquitoes. You say summer I say three month hunt for elusive shade 99.9% of teens born in summer are extraverts LMS if you are one of the 0.1% who jam to purcells when i am laid in earth whilst hating butts and sweat

 

[Ex-User (9086)]

Astrology and MBTI, somebody unpretentious has finally made that connection!

 

[TheManBeyond]

according to this:

gandhi: esfp
osama bin laden: infp
jung: entp
napoleon: istj
avril lavigne: esfp could be perhaps ¿?
cobain: enfp could be perhaps


mariah carey: intj

booom

 

[Jennywocky]

I knew Mariah was holding out on us...

 

[Alias]

Humanitarian ISFJ, huh? Hard to get wronger than that.

 

[X-Logik]

1

 

[TheManBeyond]

Hahjahah cobain the jesus of drugdealers. Imagine the scene
Im not an esfp also. If i have se it is inferior or perhaps tertiary.
Carey is not an infp either. Like hell no ever.

 

[Black Rose]

I'm INFJ/ENFJ but my profile says INFP because it was suggested I have Ne. I can't tell the difference between Ne and Ni. If there are biological differences caused by weather conditions I would like to know how that relates to the 8 functions?

P.S. what are your predictions about this in relation to transhumans?

 

[Jennywocky]

The problem isn't a matter of tweaking details, it's the methodology itself.

For example, what correlation exists at all where one might imagine a western calendar somehow directly corresponds to MBTI type? What led you to believe this is accurate?

 

[X-Logik]

1

 

[Inquisitor]

Even if the comments are bad, they are useful. Thanks again.

Last day i was trying to adjust the dates properly. There is some glitch.


Sinny91 tell she is ESTJ... maybe she is born like 2 days before INTP period. I don't know exactly. So she is mistakenly classified ESTJ.

I think also there is an error between INFP and INTP in March.

Maria Carey : her birthday is March 27, so she is probably an INFP.

Kurt Cobain is ENFJ (definitely)

When i mean Humanitarian for ISFJ i was talking about Priests and religious people.

I need to do some adjustement again. I will work on that.

Cynism is frequent among INTP, i know that because i'm one. I will try to fix the errors i made.

Are you investigating possible connections between typology and astrology by any chance?

 

[Black Rose]

Maybe you will understand better what i mean with this graphic.

[BIMG]http://img15.hostingpics.net/pics/575729Dates.jpg[/BIMG]

could you give an explanation?

why am i INFJ/ENFJ?

i was born nov 10

 

[TheManBeyond]

Naw i was born 27 september like abril lavigne
July sucks
What i find curious is that animakity is born the same say as my dad who can possibly be an intp. Also I have another friend who's born that same day and he's the most obvious entp ever

 

[X-Logik]

Very useful comment!!! themanbeyond!!

Few days ago i was questionning myself about if ENTP-ENTJ of the Upper-Right corner was instead switched with ESFP-ESFJ.

For if there is a relation with the weather.... i don't think.

It's simply synchronicity.

I only put astrology signs to be more convivial, i'm not an astrologer.

 

[Black Rose]

For if there is a relation with the weather.... i don't think.

It's simply synchronicity.

so the conditions by which a type a person becomes is more about circumstance?

my last name begins with W so I am always last in line in class so my behavior and mentality are from this. Is this what you base your chart on with its dates?

 

[Haim]

 

[X-Logik]

1

 

[Ex-User (5841)]

The political map was a lot better. This one is basically astrology (which is accurate, for people who actually believe in astrology).

I'd really respect this thread if it were for social engineering purposes.

 

[Kuu]

I would like to hear why you think that it is possible to type people based on birth day. How can such a thing actually impact the psyche of a person more than genetics? How can such a thing impact the psyche of a person more than early life experiences? Is it related to the weather? Light, temperature? What's the logic behind it? how did you come to the conclusion that typing is purely mathematical?

 

[Sinny91]

I did wonder myself if MBTI correlated with astrology, so your post has not gone to waste.

If it helps

Me INTP Sept 2nd.
My INTP cousin Nov 2nd.
MY INTP friend Nov 14th.

@Kuu, most things in life, can be proven true by mathmatics .
As an alchemist I'm sure you're aware of that

 

[X-Logik]

1

 

[onesteptwostep]

You know, this is probably how the Zodiac and its horoscopes were made :P

 

[Yellow]

Oh my goodness, this is bad. I'm apparently an ISTJ and RLOEN

My actual global five is usually RCUAI, and I test as INTP.

By the way, (and I'll just throw my birthday out there because it's a rather common one), when I was young, the horoscope cutoff placed me as a Leo. Then it changed to Virgo. Now, with the "discovery" of Ophiuchus, I'm a Leo again. Of course on this chart, I'm back to Virgo. Someone should really make up their damn minds. Not that any of the zodiac descriptions fit..

 

[RaBind]

This is hilarious. Taking the observations and empheric data out of the system to improve it.

 

[crippli]

Oh my goodness, this is bad. I'm apparently an ISTJ and RLOEN

My actual global five is usually RCUAI, and I test as INTP.

By the way, (and I'll just throw my birthday out there because it's a rather common one), when I was young, the horoscope cutoff placed me as a Leo. Then it changed to Virgo. Now, with the "discovery" of Ophiuchus, I'm a Leo again. Of course on this chart, I'm back to Virgo. Someone should really make up their damn minds. Not that any of the zodiac descriptions fit..

OMG. A cusp. Earth and fire.

Isn't the sun supposed to have been at a certain point at the time of birth, with the year. So that it should be clear what is your Star Sign?

The dates on these Star Signs are all messed up from what I've seen earlier. It tends to be +- a few days. I guess the Ophiuchus that is mentioned above.

This test labeled me as an ISTJ. I am skeptical about astronomy. So not automatically inclined to believe the verdict.

 

[X-Logik]

Too much sarcasm... this discussion turn to nowhere. There is no discussion at all, it's more like insults... I'm open to critics, but it goes too far.

Yellow don't be stupid

When someone think to a theory, first there is persons who tell you you're an idiot, that it will not work. There is the guy who already did it and who tell you not to think about it. There is the people who want you to solve the problems of the universe and the question WHY... who i am... where i go.... where i come from...

I'm here to discuss about an idea, not to write a master thesis in psychology.

i have to face also remarks from rebelious teenagers and anarchists. I prefer not to reply.

I'm INTP myself and i'm surprised to see that people are closed-minded and are so intolerant. Also, i repeat i'm not an astrologer and i don't care.

You know, i speak rarely to people. there is always sceptical folks you have to convince and this phenomenon is present on all forums. So at the end i completely stop to communicate with "normal people". It's too boring.

There is individuals in this society who want to share ideas, but they forget about it because you always have to stoop to the lowest common denominator.

I never participate in any kind of forum and this is the reasons. Last time i write something on a forum, it was maybe 2 or 3 years ago. The same thing happened.

Bye! Have a good day... or night....

 

[onesteptwostep]

It's probably just for fun, really.

But technically speaking typology is most likely rooted in nature and nurture, genetics and the environment. But yeah things like these are just for fun, I mean that's why they still print those zodiac horoscopes, whether they're Hellenistic or Chinese.

@X-Logik How big is your data, and what ethnicity have you included in them? I think you can improve your chart by enlarging your scope.

 

[Jennywocky]

Too much sarcasm... this discussion turn to nowhere. There is no discussion at all, it's more like insults... I'm open to critics, but it goes too far.

Yellow don't be stupid

When someone think to a theory, first there is persons who tell you you're an idiot, that it will not work. There is the guy who already did it and who tell you not to think about it. There is the people who want you to solve the problems of the universe and the question WHY... who i am... where i go.... where i come from...

I'm here to discuss about an idea, not to write a master thesis in psychology.

i have to face also remarks from rebelious teenagers and anarchists. I prefer not to reply.

I'm INTP myself and i'm surprised to see that people are closed-minded and are so intolerant. Also, i repeat i'm not an astrologer and i don't care.

You know, i speak rarely to people. there is always sceptical folks you have to convince and this phenomenon is present on all forums. So at the end i completely stop to communicate with "normal people". It's too boring.

There is individuals in this society who want to share ideas, but they forget about it because you always have to stoop to the lowest common denominator.

I never participate in any kind of forum and this is the reasons. Last time i write something on a forum, it was maybe 2 or 3 years ago. The same thing happened.

Bye! Have a good day... or night....

yada yada yada. A response like this suggests you're not willing to entertain actual criticism, which is why you have been receiving derision from some members. If you want to be taken seriously, especially when your ideas seem non-sensical, please go back and review these two posts and consider again the points being raised and provide some explanation:

The problem isn't a matter of tweaking details, it's the methodology itself.

For example, what correlation exists at all where one might imagine a western calendar somehow directly corresponds to MBTI type? What led you to believe this is accurate?

I would like to hear why you think that it is possible to type people based on birth day. How can such a thing actually impact the psyche of a person more than genetics? How can such a thing impact the psyche of a person more than early life experiences? Is it related to the weather? Light, temperature? What's the logic behind it? how did you come to the conclusion that typing is purely mathematical?

Seriously, you have an uphill battle here -- there are far better and more cause-effect explanations for personality type that what day of the year you happened to have been born on. You should be expecting and prepared to field a LOT of pushback on this; getting offended that you're receiving pushback will do nothing to strengthen your position. We're still waiting for some kind of predictive argument.

 

[Ex-User (5841)]

Social engineering.... something to consider seriously.

Note : HabitatDoctor do you have an idea about a good forum ?

I meant social engineering as in using this thread to collect people's birth dates. No idea about another forum unless it's an astrology one.

Birth date is probably a factor, but probably not the biggest one. People's behaviors change seasonally, as do diets (including while pregnant), and environmental variability. Students born in September are much older proportionally when they begin school (assuming school starts in August) compared to, say, one born in August that's almost a full year younger yet considered their peer.

But there's not a single variable to narrow it down to. Any birth date effects are a product of synchronicity. The effect starts out magnifying over time but then it gets more scattered with interference. It would probably be most notable in children just before puberty.

 

[Haim]

A troll,it must be,I hope.

 

[StevenM]

Looking at the calendar on this forum, it seems the birthdays are scattered fairly evenly.

 

[Thurlor]

I might be able to comment on this if there was anything other than '1' to comment on.

 

[Alias]

I think that this has some points, but the dates windows are too slim. I knew/know a SCOAI ENFJ whose birthday was close to the one on the chart. And I, a RCUEI INTP, am not far from the predicted date of December.