• OK, it's on.
  • Please note that many, many Email Addresses used for spam, are not accepted at registration. Select a respectable Free email.
  • Done now. Domine miserere nobis.

Authentic living

Architect

Professional INTP
Local time
Today 6:01 AM
Joined
Dec 25, 2010
Messages
6,691
---
Would you say you like to do things that piss people off passively? Missing family events is not a direct contact activity. I'm asking out of curiosity, not judgement.

Not sure what you mean. For that example my extended family has events that involve a lot of traveling a state away, and they do it excessively (IMO), such as a 'reunion' every blessed year for a week. Then they try to strong arm us (me, wife and kid) into going. We hate travel in general, hate the place in particular where they have it, and a tired of the sports-sports-sports culture of the event. Not to mention the boredom of the whole thing. The strong arming just makes it worse as I won't allow myself to be controlled, but they're seemingly not bright enough to realize that. Simply caring about why we don't want to go would go a long way. So we go every other year at best, and miss out on many of the other things such as weddings, funerals, etc. It's a Sensor dominant mob scene (we're the only intuitives AFAIK)

Make sense? I recognize the dynamics of the situation, I get why they are happy just to get together, chat, eat, drink and play sports. However they just seem to be bothered that "oh my gosh not everybody wants to do this" without actually trying to find out why that might be. I'm happy with people doing their own thing as long as people don't get in a huff over it.
 

E404

Obsessions of an INTP
Local time
Today 6:01 AM
Joined
Sep 28, 2016
Messages
229
---
Location
USA
Not sure what you mean. For that example my extended family has events that involve a lot of traveling a state away, and they do it excessively (IMO), such as a 'reunion' every blessed year for a week. Then they try to strong arm us (me, wife and kid) into going. We hate travel in general, hate the place in particular where they have it, and a tired of the sports-sports-sports culture of the event. Not to mention the boredom of the whole thing. The strong arming just makes it worse as I won't allow myself to be controlled, but they're seemingly not bright enough to realize that. Simply caring about why we don't want to go would go a long way. So we go every other year at best, and miss out on many of the other things such as weddings, funerals, etc. It's a Sensor dominant mob scene (we're the only intuitives AFAIK)

Make sense? I recognize the dynamics of the situation, I get why they are happy just to get together, chat, eat, drink and play sports. However they just seem to be bothered that "oh my gosh not everybody wants to do this" without actually trying to find out why that might be. I'm happy with people doing their own thing as long as people don't get in a huff over it.

Yes, that makes sense. I was wondering if the general statement of feeling the need to do things that "piss people off" was generally in a passive way since you also said you don't like to disrupt things. But there is actually a bit of understandable reasoning for not wanting to go to family reunions, especially in that case and I get it now.

Isn't funny how people feel the need to control others?
 

bvanevery

Redshirt who doesn't die
Local time
Today 8:01 AM
Joined
Jan 3, 2016
Messages
1,480
---
Location
Asheville, NC
Once you're okay with people not accepting or liking the way you live, it gets fairly easy. In my experience that is. It can be difficult to feel like it's okay if you've been made to feel bad for wanting something.

This is a recurring problem for people in the Recovering From Religion group that I help out with. 'People' is one thing; family is quite another. I think half of our time is spent trying to armor the group members from their parents giving them shit.

I'm sure this can be true of any family schism that has some kind of ideological or cultural basis. I had a friend back in high school who was Indian, who said his Dad would "kill him" if he was caught doing certain things. I doubt that was meant literally, but I think he was under strong pressure to conform to his Dad's idea of what his future should be.
 

Architect

Professional INTP
Local time
Today 6:01 AM
Joined
Dec 25, 2010
Messages
6,691
---
Yes, that makes sense. I was wondering if the general statement of feeling the need to do things that "piss people off" was generally in a passive way since you also said you don't like to disrupt things. But there is actually a bit of understandable reasoning for not wanting to go to family reunions, especially in that case and I get it now.

Yeah it's really a personality difference - they're all religious, sporty, etc, and we're the rare birds. Everybody likes each other, and we're well liked I think, but it still is a problem.

Would bringing a chess board, or such, help?

Good thought. I got into photography for this reason. It wasn't conscious on my part, and while I enjoyed it in a way, it was also a bit pathological. Finally figured out that I was using the photography as a crutch - trying to find a way to enjoy outdoorsy, traveling, sporty kind of living. An engagement tool. But photography isn't really that interesting to me and takes a lot of time and effort, so I ditched it.

Yeah gave up on trying to find something like that as a middle ground, it never works out. Plus it wouldn't be such a problem if it wasn't the expense, a day long drive, continual driving around when we get there, staying in hotels, the food, etc. A big sensory management fest.
 

QuickTwist

Spiritual "Woo"
Local time
Today 7:01 AM
Joined
Jan 24, 2013
Messages
7,182
---
Location
...
I believe I said in the Absurdity thread (haven't opened the link that EyeSeeCold linked to reread) that People are unique no matter what they do. Having said that I think what Architect poses is a good exercise in evaluating one's life circumstances and routines to see if there is anything that could be improved upon in terms of doing what makes you happy/content/fulfilled/gives you peace of mind. These things are important and I think bringing to light what these things are and how to do them has a lot of value.
 

bvanevery

Redshirt who doesn't die
Local time
Today 8:01 AM
Joined
Jan 3, 2016
Messages
1,480
---
Location
Asheville, NC
staying in hotels,

How camping friendly are you? or the location? You've got tent, hammock, and cabin camping. There's car camping if you have enough car space, but you said you're hauling a family around.

the food,
Bring / buy your own.

etc. A big sensory management fest.
I don't see "food from a car" as any kind of big deal, but of course I've been living with a 55 gal. Coleman cooler for most of 7 years now. I don't have to cook if I don't want to. I eat fine; I do tend towards a lot of dairy. I'm not into cans all that much. Usually when I cook, it's because I'm unwilling to deal with preserved meats anymore.

You could try artistic stuff, like "Blair Witchcraft" art projects, or spray painting a big cloth. Or maybe you like some 'sports' better than others, i.e. croquet or badminton rather than volleyball. I just wouldn't take a family gathering 'lying down' if I really was bored with most of their events. I'd put something in the mix that I like, so that I wouldn't be bored. That's as simple as asserting leadership and actually doing it. In a large enough gathering, you'll probably find some takers for whatever you're on about.

Make 'em all weave baskets lol.

Papier mache.
 

QuickTwist

Spiritual "Woo"
Local time
Today 7:01 AM
Joined
Jan 24, 2013
Messages
7,182
---
Location
...
How camping friendly are you? or the location? You've got tent, hammock, and cabin camping. There's car camping if you have enough car space, but you said you're hauling a family around.

Bring / buy your own.

I don't see "food from a car" as any kind of big deal, but of course I've been living with a 55 gal. Coleman cooler for most of 7 years now. I don't have to cook if I don't want to. I eat fine; I do tend towards a lot of dairy. I'm not into cans all that much. Usually when I cook, it's because I'm unwilling to deal with preserved meats anymore.

You could try artistic stuff, like "Blair Witchcraft" art projects, or spray painting a big cloth. Or maybe you like some 'sports' better than others, i.e. croquet or badminton rather than volleyball. I just wouldn't take a family gathering 'lying down' if I really was bored with most of their events. I'd put something in the mix that I like, so that I wouldn't be bored. That's as simple as asserting leadership and actually doing it. In a large enough gathering, you'll probably find some takers for whatever you're on about.

Make 'em all weave baskets lol.

Papier mache.

Why are you doing this, trying to impose what you think on someone else? Architect is not dumb, I'm sure he has tried to solve his problem and it doesn't sound like he is asking for your advice.
 

bvanevery

Redshirt who doesn't die
Local time
Today 8:01 AM
Joined
Jan 3, 2016
Messages
1,480
---
Location
Asheville, NC
Why are you doing this, trying to impose what you think on someone else?

Why am I making suggestions? Because he perhaps hasn't thought of some options.

Architect is not dumb,
I seriously doubt that's the issue here. Never even crossed my mind, that he might be dumb. Why would it figure into your reasoning?

I'm sure he has tried to solve his problem
Ever heard the expression, "That was then and this is now?" Sometimes when we get disgusted and throw up our hands about something, revisiting it a few years later can bring a different perspective to it. It's very clear to me that Architect experiences a great deal of emotional negativity even thinking about having to interact with this situation. For all I know that could be totally valid, his relatives could be a totally insufferable PITA. However, there are other possibilities. Dividing the problem, and taking ownership of a piece of it like, "Hey, here's my giant papier mache chess board, now who's playing chess with me??" might be an answer.

Usually when I get impatient with someone else's "free advice", it's because they're repeating a list of steps that I've already taken or discarded, and simply haven't had time to tell them all the things I did already. I don't tend to get my feathers ruffled when someone suggests something new, that I hadn't considered.

It's also difficult for me to visualize disliking all of one's relatives. Although, I realize that's definitely possible with some families. In that case I'm tempted to think the complaint is simpler, i.e. "I can't stand them!" 'Cuz they're emotionally abusive or all shallow gold diggers or racist conservatives or members of a religious cult or some other horrible thing. "They're doing stuff at a gathering that I don't think is fun, and costs too much money and effort to go do" doesn't sound like that to me.

and it doesn't sound like he is asking for your advice.
This is a public forum. People can say whatever they want about what someone else says. You seem to have a pretty strong interpretation about where this conversation was inevitably going. I don't see why you should though.

'Cuz I'm a 'P'. :cool:
 

QuickTwist

Spiritual "Woo"
Local time
Today 7:01 AM
Joined
Jan 24, 2013
Messages
7,182
---
Location
...

Its funny. You must think of yourself as some kind of savior who can solve everyone's problems for them because you think of yourself as smarter than everyone else. Naive.
 

Architect

Professional INTP
Local time
Today 6:01 AM
Joined
Dec 25, 2010
Messages
6,691
---
How camping friendly are you? or the location? You've got tent, hammock, and cabin camping ...

The thing you don't know is I have a family - INFJ wife and INTP son, both who are loath to rough it, and who both have their own issues with it I have to work with. I used to do such things just for the minimalist adventure of it but neither of them are into that game. Plus the expense, take a trip and start adding a multiplayer when you have a family (think, say a plane trip is $400, but you have to buy three tickets, hotel, food for three, ground transport ... just a next state hop starts getting into a few thousand easy).

I appreciate your suggestions, and QuickTwists relevant comments, but I have been all over this issue and there's no simple answer. It's a fairly common pattern with large ES dominant families, the Kennedy's were like this. I think Jackie was the lone intuitive who had equal difficulty with them.
 

bvanevery

Redshirt who doesn't die
Local time
Today 8:01 AM
Joined
Jan 3, 2016
Messages
1,480
---
Location
Asheville, NC
Its funny. You must think of yourself as some kind of savior who can solve everyone's problems for them because you think of yourself as smarter than everyone else. Naive.

Ok, are we having the "P vs. J" or the "T vs. F" conflict here? Name the way you aren't INTP.
 

bvanevery

Redshirt who doesn't die
Local time
Today 8:01 AM
Joined
Jan 3, 2016
Messages
1,480
---
Location
Asheville, NC
The thing you don't know is I have a family - INFJ wife and INTP son, both who are loath to rough it, and who both have their own issues with it I have to work with. I used to do such things just for the minimalist adventure of it but neither of them are into that game.

Pity.

We had some family squabbling recently about my sister coming down to Charleston to see my Dad. It hadn't happened in a long time, and my Dad put pressure on her to "make it so". Her husband didn't wanna! But I personally thought it was pretty important to get some actual father / daughter time going on, and I had intoned as much through diplomatic back channels. Ultimately, my sister went down there and dragged everyone else with them. Going down only by herself, was a possible scenario that I personally think needed to happen if her husband wasn't willing.

I think the point is, sometimes you have to drag the troops with you, kicking and screaming. And my sister does not like to assert herself about things like this. But I don't think she's incapable of it.

Of course the other lesson, is this only works if you yourself see value in the venture. If you yourself have cold feet, I don't know that I as a stranger am going to persuade you about the value of family ties. "I don't like what they do... " just wouldn't stop me. They are family. They'd have to be really ugly people on the inside, for me to avoid them.

Plus the expense, take a trip and start adding a multiplayer when you have a family (think, say a plane trip is $400, but you have to buy three tickets, hotel, food for three, ground transport ... just a next state hop starts getting into a few thousand easy).
For a family, it's economically irrational to take a plane 1 state over. Often even several states over. You do have 2 adult drivers, who I'm assuming can switch off, so I'm not really seeing the problem there. My Mom is in her 60s and was managing 10 hour drives by herself, although now she's sick of it and says she's gonna fly from now on. She has the money and it's only her going, so not that big a deal for her.

You can buy groceries. You don't have to eat out. No, food on the road is not that tiring to deal with. Cooler, sandwich stuff, yogurt, vegetables, whatever. I live this way permanently. Helps that literally half my life is at a grocery store, to get the free electricity and wifi. Anyways even if you do intend to eat out sometimes for convenience, carting your own groceries around greatly alleviates the cost. My family bought "breakfast and lunch" stuff even when visiting the Cayman Islands, not a cheap trip by any means. It can also just be faster than sit down service. Eat and go.

Motel expense doesn't sound like it's going away in your case. They can be made to have microwaves or mini-kitchens. Failing that, bring a hotplate. I mostly cook with an electric skillet I got from the Goodwill for $10. They retail for about $20.

I appreciate your suggestions, and QuickTwists relevant comments, but I have been all over this issue and there's no simple answer. It's a fairly common pattern with large ES dominant families, the Kennedy's were like this. I think Jackie was the lone intuitive who had equal difficulty with them.
I'm not buying that it's an 'N' problem. Sure, they all want to do different stuff than you... but isn't the real problem, that you don't want to have to assert yourself to do something else? That sounds more like an 'I' problem.

I'm 'I' but not strongly so. I'd just assert myself and we'd do something else. Not everyone, of course, but I'd find my contingent and my time slot. And if my first attempt didn't 'sell', I'd try something else. I think I'd find something.

Ever played the game "Mad Libs" ? That would probably work.

Backgammon is a good game for stupid people, that won't bore you for a little while at least. You can try making deliberately bad moves if it's not challenging enough. They probably won't notice.

There are some good casual dice games of the "press your luck" variety that can be common ground. I recommend "Inca Gold". Technically I guess that's "cards being turned up randomly", not dice. Too many cards turn up, and the tomb collapses. Your job is to get massive wealth before it does. If everyone else bails out early, you have more loot to take!
 

QuickTwist

Spiritual "Woo"
Local time
Today 7:01 AM
Joined
Jan 24, 2013
Messages
7,182
---
Location
...
Ok, are we having the "P vs. J" or the "T vs. F" conflict here? Name the way you aren't INTP.

I believe AK said it well here: http://intpforum.com/showpost.php?p=546728&postcount=32

Anyways, the older I get the more I think I am probably closer to ISTP than anything else.. So you would be wrong that I am either a J or F type.

I don't really understand when this became about my type, however. I haven't engaged much with you for a few reasons:

  1. You are interested in things that do not interest me. This is the primary reason.
  2. You like debating with people, I don't.
  3. You solicit advice to people whether they are asking for it or not, again, I don't.
  4. You don't come across as someone who is trying to learn from people.
  5. The only cause I see you fighting for is projection of fighting against the norm. This is fine except what goes along with that is for you to give your opinion on things that don't look to be any primary concern to you and your soul purpose becomes fighting the norm and not what arguments are actually being held.
 

bvanevery

Redshirt who doesn't die
Local time
Today 8:01 AM
Joined
Jan 3, 2016
Messages
1,480
---
Location
Asheville, NC
Anyways, the older I get the more I think I am probably closer to ISTP than anything else.. So you would be wrong that I am either a J or F type.

I wouldn't have anticipated a 'S' vs. 'N' conflict. FWIW I am overwhelmingly 'N'. Like always scoring 90%. I've had innumerable NP vs. SJ conflicts over the years, but this didn't seem like one of them.

I don't really understand when this became about my type, however.

When you started chewing me out, out of the blue, for what I was posting. I know I didn't say anything highly offensive to Architect, and as a fairly strong 'T' I expect people in an INTP forum to take things somewhat objectively. Yet for some reason you came on as though I was trying to inflict mortal wounds.

You are interested in things that do not interest me. This is the primary reason.

Well that could easily be a 'S' vs. 'N' conflict.



You like debating with people, I don't.


I'm not familiar with whether the MBTI would explain that. I definitely don't apologize for enjoying debate with people on a public web forum. AFAIAC it's the venue for that sort of thing. I also do it in real life face-to-face groups, i.e. the Asheville Skeptics.


You solicit advice to people whether they are asking for it or not, again, I don't.


I have no hangup about it. You seem to, that this is some 'big wrong'. It's what you started chewing me out about.



I'll be honest: one thing I don't like, is when people complain about things and aren't at all solutions oriented. Doesn't mean there actually is a solution, but people shouldn't be afraid of looking for and discussing such. Some people really don't want answers though. They just want to vent, and to receive moral support for their attitudes while they're venting. They want affirmation and not any kind of challenge. In some cases, I'm not prepared to give affirmation, because I don't agree with the stance from which their venting comes.



For instance in this thread:

  • "I don't like the activities they do." Extended family bonds are much more important to me than specific activities, so I would overcome this problem by leading with activities that I like.
  • "Other family members don't want to do things." I'd make them do it, at some frequency they could tolerate. It would probably mean I'd have to do something else they want to do, in exchange, that I don't like so much. I don't have a problem with taking turns being happy.
  • "It's expensive". I'd work on reducing expenses. Heck I live my whole life that way! But I do realize there are limits to how much expense one can reduce. At some point the balance sheet may say, "Nope. Ain't happening."
Now, Architect as we all know is a bright guy and he'll navigate these hazards just fine. It doesn't hurt to remind people of the obvious from time to time though.



BTW from a dating and marriage standpoint I'll offer this sage advice: if you partner with someone who doesn't basically like doing what you like to do, you're going to have trouble. Which can ultimately end in a breakup or divorce. Example: I like to go out and do stuff, she's a homebody. Been there done that. Saw my Mom and Dad get divorced during their retirement, partly driven by that sort of thing.


You don't come across as someone who is trying to learn from people.



The only cause I see you fighting for is projection of fighting against the norm. This is fine except what goes along with that is for you to give your opinion on things that don't look to be any primary concern to you and your soul purpose becomes fighting the norm and not what arguments are actually being held.

I think this is all 'you' and not much to do with me. I've been listening to that ISTP video in the background as I've been typing this. You're just being blunt and simplifying, and from my INTP perspective, to no purpose.
 

QuickTwist

Spiritual "Woo"
Local time
Today 7:01 AM
Joined
Jan 24, 2013
Messages
7,182
---
Location
...
I'm not even going to respond to that. Having this pointless back and forth with you serves no purpose. I already said what I had to say.
 

Architect

Professional INTP
Local time
Today 6:01 AM
Joined
Dec 25, 2010
Messages
6,691
---

Yeah actually it's getting a little tiresome. It wasn't a major point, there's little use in anybody trying to solve it through a text stream, I'm not actually looking for any suggestions, and I basically solved the problem anyhow. Thanks regardless -
 
Top Bottom