• OK, it's on.
  • Please note that many, many Email Addresses used for spam, are not accepted at registration. Select a respectable Free email.
  • Done now. Domine miserere nobis.

Brain Response Determined More by Personality Type Than by Thought

Da Blob

Banned
Local time
Today 8:37 AM
Joined
Dec 19, 2008
Messages
5,926
---
Location
Oklahoma
This could be a very interesting thing. Has anyone done fMRI scans to detect the differences between the 16 types - not just the E/I scale?



"Turhan Canli, PhD, a psychologist from Stanford University, and colleagues used functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) to measure the relation between brain responses to emotional stimuli — pictures. While in a fMRI scanner, 14 healthy 19- to 42-year-old women's brain reactions to pictures containing negative images (crying or angry people, spiders, guns, or a cemetery) or positive images (happy couple, puppies, foods like ice cream or brownies, or sunsets) that provoked strong emotional reactions were determined. A personality measure was also used to help the researchers determine the participants' level of extraversion — the tendency to be optimistic and sociable — and their level of neuroticism — the tendency to be anxious, worried, and socially insecure.

The fMRI results show that the women who scored high on extraversion also had greater brain reactivity to positive stimuli compared with negative stimuli than did those women who scored low on extraversion. The associations between extraversion and neural activity in response to positive images were observable in several areas of the brain that control emotion, including the frontal cortex, amygdala, and anterior cingulate.

For the women who scored low on extraversion, no brain reactivity to positive stimuli was found. But those who scored high on the neuroticism measures had more brain reactions to negative stimuli, but in fewer parts of the brain that control emotions..."


EDIT: personally I do not think it is valid to assume that introversion is a symptom of a mental disorder such as neuroticism - but then I am not a researcher at Stanford...
 

Da Blob

Banned
Local time
Today 8:37 AM
Joined
Dec 19, 2008
Messages
5,926
---
Location
Oklahoma

Anthile

Steel marks flesh
Local time
Today 3:37 PM
Joined
Jan 10, 2009
Messages
3,987
---
Meh, nowadays everything is a mental disorder. I think that most of them are rubbish. You could even say that eating broccoli is a mental disorder if you find enough people to agree with you.
As much as I enjoy learning about the field of psychology, some things are certainly wrong there.
 

Da Blob

Banned
Local time
Today 8:37 AM
Joined
Dec 19, 2008
Messages
5,926
---
Location
Oklahoma
Yeah! I agree with the above comments. IMO the research is trash, I hope it was not financed by taxpayers...

The things that caught my interest was the title and the fact that personality traits may be 'visible'. If this observation, that personality creates brain activity, is true - it has wide implications and basically refutes the idea that we all are just products of our environment and the stimuli thereof. We are NOT driven by the content of our perceptions of the environment...

If personality traits are observable and can be 'measured' in an objective manner it moves personality theory into the realm of the scientific. THe MBTI might finally get the scientific validation that has been lacking necessary for it to be employed in a number of settings, such as part of the educational curriculum for the GP...
 

Cogwulf

Is actually an INTJ
Local time
Today 2:37 PM
Joined
Aug 21, 2009
Messages
1,544
---
Location
England
EDIT: personally I do not think it is valid to assume that introversion is a symptom of a mental disorder such as neuroticism - but then I am not a researcher at Stanford...

I think they're referring to neuroticism as one of the "big five" personality traits, not as a disorder
 

Agent Intellect

Absurd Anti-hero.
Local time
Today 9:37 AM
Joined
Jul 28, 2008
Messages
4,113
---
Location
Michigan
There is a study on the official MBTI website where they did an EEG of people from the different personality types. I posted this in the thread "Official MBTI online?".

The problem I've always had with psychology, in particular when talking about psychological disorders, is the absence of a control in experimentation - what constitutes a 'normal' brain? It's the same with the MBTI types; we can't really compare each type to a neutral type (a theoretical "XXXX" type), only to each other. It's like testing a new medication only in comparison to people using other medications.

To me, psychology has always been to neuroscience (I hesitate to call it "neuro"science anymore - see signature) what philosophy is to science in general. Psychology, like philosophy, is all thinking, and 'thought experiments' without any hard data. I think there needs to be a lot more brain scan studies with personality in mind.
 

Da Blob

Banned
Local time
Today 8:37 AM
Joined
Dec 19, 2008
Messages
5,926
---
Location
Oklahoma
There is a study on the official MBTI website where they did an EEG of people from the different personality types. I posted this in the thread "Official MBTI online?".

The problem I've always had with psychology, in particular when talking about psychological disorders, is the absence of a control in experimentation - what constitutes a 'normal' brain? It's the same with the MBTI types; we can't really compare each type to a neutral type (a theoretical "XXXX" type), only to each other. It's like testing a new medication only in comparison to people using other medications.

To me, psychology has always been to neuroscience (I hesitate to call it "neuro"science anymore - see signature) what philosophy is to science in general. Psychology, like philosophy, is all thinking, and 'thought experiments' without any hard data. I think there needs to be a lot more brain scan studies with personality in mind.

Ditto!

The problem with psychology is that it is a branch of philosophy that tried to remove itself from the Arts into the Sciences before any appropriate tools were available. Using Statistics as a mere fig leaf in that regard. However, the fMRI is a fabulous piece of technology and offers a real tool to study the 'real' mind that was previously just a topic for speculation. It may well be that any 'psychological' works prior to the advent of the fMRI will be classified by the historians of the future as 'mere' philosophy...
 

INTPINFP

Active Member
Local time
Today 2:37 PM
Joined
Oct 27, 2008
Messages
285
---
Location
surburbs
theyll say anything to get dumb parents to buy pills :)
 
Top Bottom